Gloriana or the Unfulfilled Queen | |||||||
Michael Moorcock | |||||||
Gollancz, 368 pages | |||||||
|
A review by David Soyka
Although an author's note pointedly claims that his novel is not "Elizabethan Fantasia," it does draw upon Edmund Spenser's famous
poem, The Fairie Queen. The queen in question was Elizabeth I, the Virgin Queen, so called because of her refusal to marry and share
her power. While it provided certain diplomatic flexibility and maintained Britain's independence in not literally being wed to another
political faction, it also resulted in some civil uncertainty in not producing a direct heir. Among other names, Spenser refers to Elizabeth
as Gloriana. In Michael Moorcock's version, Gloriana is "unfulfilled" in a sexual sense that subverts the notion of a "virgin queen" in ways it
was never intended. Thanks to Captain Quire -- an anti-hero who kills without remorse in furtherance of his art, i.e., the ordering of events
towards some greater purpose, albeit a purpose ostensibly defined by whoever employs him -- Gloriana ultimately does becomes fulfilled, though
not quite in the way you might expect.
It does seem, at first, a bit strange, then, to claim this is not an Elizabethan fantasy, given its setting and allusions to a famous
Elizabethan poem. Despite some talk about visitors from alternate worlds -- a sort of kidding aside in that the realm of Albion is an alternate
England and that these visitors, such as one "Adlophus Hiddlerus," come from "our" world -- and mechanical creatures, these are merely
sidebars. For those who like to split hairs over such things, this is strictly speaking a romance rather than a fantasy. And because it is
a romance, you know that somehow or another, despite how Gloriana and her realm are plunged into the deepest tragedy, things will work out
happily. And they do, but you have to read closely for the irony in how they work out and that this particular resolution is a bit
different from the typical "happily ever after." Indeed, the "somehow or another" in which the noble if anguished Gloriana and the
nihilistic opportunist Quire properly consume their relationship and compensate for all the wrongs, unwitting (Gloriana's) or
witting (Quire's), is certainly not conventional for the genre, fantasy or romance or whatever. In its place is a feminist statement, all
the more ironical, perhaps, in that a male author makes it.
As I am writing this, the clearly defined forces of good and evil, Christians and devils but both in pagan garb, are poised to clash in
Dolby Surround Sound at your local cinema; meanwhile, back in a "real world" of economic uncertainty, the prospect of actual conflict in
which the corpses do not arise after the director yells, "Cut," is simplistically characterized as a struggle between "good"
and "evil." Gloriana or the Unfulfilled Queen subverts the
traditional fantasy tropes epitomized by Tolkien and turned into commercial hash by his many
derivatives, as well as the romantic idealism of the medieval poets where such work finds its roots. At the same time, and perhaps more of
interest, it rails at the rotting undercarriage of the general body politic. Also noteworthy is that Gloriana was written long ago in
a universe far away, but still not so different from ours -- 1978. It reappears today thanks to the Fantasy Masterworks series of
Gollancz as Volume #22, and the author says that it is "significantly revised from all previous English language editions." Though I read
this around the time of its first incarnation, I can't really say what the revisions are or how they change the narrative, for better or
worse. I can say that it remains relevant and a hearty antidote to much of the crap that is being peddled these days, whether by fantasy
book publishers or the political fantasies of world leaders. And, even if it weren't, it's still a helluva lot of fun to read.
David Soyka is a former journalist and college teacher who writes the occasional short story and freelance article. He makes a living writing corporate marketing communications, which is a kind of fiction without the art. |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
If you find any errors, typos or anything else worth mentioning,
please send it to editor@sfsite.com.
Copyright © 1996-2014 SF Site All Rights Reserved Worldwide