| Parallax View | ||||||||
| Keith Brooke and Eric Brown | ||||||||
| Sarob Press, 175 pages | ||||||||
|
A review by Nick Gevers
But that qualification: collaboration, complete literary harmony, can be difficult to perfect -- and the authorial tones
of Brooke and Brown are not easily reconcilable. Brown is a romantic after the school of Thomas Hardy; he evokes artistic
and erotic obsessions which, displaced to intensely realized alien locations, become exaggerated and often fatal, to moody
effect at times overwrought. Brooke, on the other hand, is an often dour practitioner of hard SF with strong, even harsh,
left wing political subtexts. And while this contrast certainly permits a marriage of strengths, it can also result in a
dampening sort of feedback: simply put, dour romanticism, passion without poetry. The stories in Parallax View are deeply
felt, and frequently contain a genuine emotional power; but a lighter, more lyrical touch would invigorate and attune them.
That said, there is a good deal to praise here. Two solo pieces exemplify the authors' separate aptitudes:
Brown's "A Prayer for the Dead," a first-person account of a carefree yet turbulent youth spent on a world whose sun is soon
to go nova, evolves into a moving meditation on many kinds of loss, the loss of youth, love, opportunity, and home prominent
among them; and Brooke's "Jurassic and the Great Tree" is an effective take on environmental conservation in which the
(alien) environment itself takes charge, in a memorably grotesque manner. The six collaborations vary in quality. At their
best, they combine the wondrous exotic inventiveness of Cordwainer Smith (as in the deployment of peculiar modes of
psychically convoluted space travel) with the dire existential insights of James Tiptree, Jr. (reflected particularly
in a recurring sense of how primordial biological imperatives can sunder "higher" human aspirations). Three tales in
this vein stand out as the finest entries in Parallax View: "The Flight of the Oh Carollian," whose protagonist
must sacrifice the wonders of the firmament for the sake of his mundanely alienated son; "Under Antares," which
intensifies that paternal dilemma to the extremity of death, and a nasty alien-inflicted agony of a death at that;
and "The Denebian Cycle," a novella which out-Tiptrees Tiptree in its feminist gallows humour at the expense of arrogant
masculine sentience...
"Sugar and Spice," which leans heavily toward the Brownian side of the creative equation here represented, is also quite
impressive, in its (admittedly a little contrived) summary of one of the fundamental dilemmas of Art: how justified are
religious moralists who judge an artist to be a sinner, simply because her work has provoked unholy murderous passions
in one unstable person? Ambiguity attends this interstellar clash of world-views, quite fittingly. But two other pieces
are distinctly less satisfactory: "Appassionata," a near-future description of love between two musical geniuses, only
one of whom is real, is mawkish and facile, and oddly ill-considered (why choose "Beethoven" as a protagonist, rather
than some more spontaneously romantic figure, one less cerebral, less deaf?); and "Mind's Eye" is dull hurried
cyberpunk, a moral parable without credibility or force. But overall...
Overall, two turkeys are easily outweighed by six solid and accomplished ventures into dangerous future
terrain. Keith Brooke and Eric Brown are not powerful stylists, and dour romanticism can be a turn-off; but their
vision is clear, their imaginative reach is profound, and their stories, as Stephen Baxter asserts in
his Foreword, are exemplary of Science Fiction's capacity to interrogate the universe itself in the service of humanity
and humane understanding. Parallax View is indeed a showcase of serious mature SF, and well deserves to be read.
Since completing a Ph.D. on uses of history in SF, Nick Gevers has become a moderately prolific reviewer and interviewer in the field of speculative fiction. He has published in INTERZONE, NOVA EXPRESS, the NEW YORK REVIEW OF SF, and GALAXIES; much of his work is available at INFINITY PLUS, of which he is Associate Editor. He lives in Cape Town, South Africa. |
|||||||
|
|
If you find any errors, typos or anything else worth mentioning,
please send it to editor@sfsite.com.
Copyright © 1996-2013 SF Site All Rights Reserved Worldwide