| The Ant-Men of Tibet and Other Stories | |||||
| edited by David Pringle | |||||
| Big Engine, 255 pages | |||||
| A review by Greg L. Johnson
Ant-Men is not really a best-of collection, more of a sampling of recent work by writers who have
come to be associated with Interzone. As such, it showcases a variety of material, both SF and
fantasy, and the quality varies as much as the content.
The good stuff is easy to pick out. Peter T. Garrat's "The Collectivization of Transylvania" puts the Dracula
legend to good use during the fall of communism in Romania. Keith Brooke's "The People of the Sea" also uses an
historical period to good effect, this time 18th century England, to tell a tale of mermaids, fathers, and
shifting time-lines.
"Byrd Land Six" by Alastair Reynolds is the best straight science fiction story in the collection, with a more
sympathetic cast of characters than is found in his novels and an affective scientific puzzle. It provides a good
contrast to Eric Brown's "Vulpheous", which strives for a similar emotional impact as "Byrd Land" but, which,
instead of making its point through the characters, uses a surprise ending to hammer the emotions home. It
nearly ruins an otherwise good story.
Jayme Lynn Blaschke's "The Dust", on the other hand, is either a parody so subtle that its wit completely
escaped me, or an attempt at light-hearted space adventure that fails on every level, from story to
characterization to language. Given the horrible dialogue and clichéd attempts at exposition, I have to
believe it's the latter.
Those are the highs and the lows, the good news is the remaining stories are closer to the top than the
bottom. In most respects, The Ant-Men of Tibet is a decent collection, and a good example of the
strengths, and occasional weaknesses, of one of the world's premiere science fiction magazines.
After judging stories from one of the field's best-known magazines, Interzone, reviewer Greg L.Johnson can turn to his duties as associate editor of Tales of the Unanticipated, one of the field's lesser-known magazines. His reviews also appear in The New York Review of Science Fiction. | |||||
|
|
If you find any errors, typos or other stuff worth mentioning,
please send it to editor@sfsite.com.
Copyright © 1996-2013 SF Site All Rights Reserved Worldwide