| Beyond His Dark Materials: Innocence and Experience in the Fiction of Philip Pullman | ||||||
| Susan Redington Bobby | ||||||
| McFarland, 207 pages | ||||||
| A review by Nathan Brazil
It should be noted that the clue is in the title, and what is under discussion here is indeed beyond His Dark Materials. Those
works are mentioned and referenced, but this is not a book where the trilogy, specifically, is examined in great depth. Instead,
Susan Redington Bobby concentrates on Pullman's other works, including his stand-alone titles, the Sally Lockheart books,
and his short stories. Among the themes put under the author's microscope -- as related to Pullman -- are fairy tale and
folklore revisions, quest-driven tales, the influence of German Romanticism and the Gothic, orphaned displaced and dispossessed
children, socially conscious penny dreadfuls, fantasy and realism through social satire, and the impacts of the sins of the
father in young adult contemporary novels.
If the above description makes the book sound rather intellectual and somewhat lacking in fun, it's because Beyond His
Dark Materials is not intended to compete with that which it describes. As an assistant professor of English at Wesley
College, Delaware, Bobby teaches classic and contemporary fairy tales and adolescent literature. Writing fantasy novels is
not her game. This book is intended for the purpose of academic reference, and as a catalyst for further discussion within
such circles. If the question was whether Beyond His Dark Materials is a Bobby dazzler, my answer would have to be
no. Especially when the price of $40 for paperback or almost $25 for a Kindle version is taken into consideration. But, for
readers interested in having Pullman's themes examined in an almost forensic manner, or for those engaged in academic study
of fantasy works, this book may have a place on the shelf.
|
||||||
|
|
If you find any errors, typos or anything else worth mentioning,
please send it to editor@sfsite.com.
Copyright © 1996-2013 SF Site All Rights Reserved Worldwide