Steampunk II: Steampunk Reloaded | |||||||||||
edited by Ann and Jeff VanderMeer | |||||||||||
Tachyon Publications, 432 pages | |||||||||||
|
A review by David Soyka
I'm not really sure why. Maybe it has something to do with my mid-century childhood when special effects
for SF films and television were cobbled together in much the same way as steampunk technology, with all the
gears and inner workings clearly visible. Or from watching The Avengers television series,
featuring the suave gentleman John Steed, impeccably outfitted in vest, bowler hat and matching umbrella as
he flirted with every male (and maybe some female) adolescent's wet dream, Emma Peel while defeating that
week's threat to the British Empire. Or my father's workshop equipped with weighty tools made out of steel
with nary a piece of plastic in sight, in an era where things were supposed to last, not tossed out as last
year's (or month's) phenomenon now hopelessly outdated in lacking some technological feature you never
used much anyways.
Which brings me to Steampunk II: Steampunk Reloaded edited by Ann and Jeff VanderMeer, the anthologists
of record for such subgenres as New Weird and pirates as well as the subject matter at hand. The various
VanderMeer collections stand out because of their sense of humor about genre classification lacking in most
academic treatments and that they supplement terrific fiction with offbeat critical discussions, typography
and other diversions of interest. A prime example here is "A Secret History of Steampunk," a collage
incorporating graphics, multiple authors, and just plain weirdness to satirize the academic research and
discussion of obscure literary fragments. There's also an excerpt of a satirical web-based comic
concerning the imagined John Stead/Emma Peel-like adventures of two real pioneers of computing
technology -- Ada Lovelace, the only legitimate daughter of Lord Byron considered to be one of the first
computer programmers, and Charles Babbage, who conceived the "Difference Engine," the first computer
prototype. Funny stuff.
Having overlooked the first VanderMeer collection of steampunk (a situation I intend to correct), I was
unawares that steampunk is more than SF/Fantasy in an anachronistic setting; it's also a lifestyle, a
reaction to our technological throwaway culture. In addition to steampunk fashion, arts and home
decoration, there is an overarching "maker" esthetic intent somewhat akin to ham radio and computer
hobbyists who built their own technology from scrap parts. The cyberpunks may have Second Life, but
the steampunks have hand-made corsets.
"History would seem to indicate that the literature came first and the fashion second," however, as Gail
Carriger points out in her essay, "Which is Mightier, the Pen or the Parasol?" (p. 396). And the results
of the pen (I'm guessing most steampunk authors don't resort to this writing instrument to compose their
stories, though they may outfit their computers in leather and brass to look like old typewriters -- Google
steampunk computers or steampunk keyboards to see some very cool retro looks) are what count here. Indeed,
the editors claim that "more steampunk short fiction is being written than ever before in the
history of the subgenre" (p. 11).
So it seems an odd choice to kick off the collection with William Gibson's "The Gernsback Continuum," a
satire of the 1930s conceptualization of the future which is our present, and generally acknowledged as the
progenitor of yet another subgenre called "raygun gothic." A few other stories, such as Samantha Henderson's
fusing the Fae with Native American creation myth in "Wild Copper" would also seem to be tangentially
steampunk for purists who insist on Victorian costumes and tin shears. However, no need to blow your bowler
as most of the content adheres to formula, without being formulaic. There's even a "proto-steampunk"
tale, "(Flying Fish) Prometheus," which concerns an aero contraption modeled after the creature of the title
that enjoys a pre-iceberg hitting Titanic reputation epitomizing safe travel courtesy of "modern"
technology; alas, as the title also implies, it also earns a post-Titanic reputation. Written by Vilhelm
Bergsøe in 1870 for a Danish newspaper, the story telling has such modern sensibilities that at first I
thought it might be a fabricated put-on (apparently it's not).
Whatever you want to call them, many of these tales are positively brilliant. Margo Lanagan's "Machine Made"
is a disturbing fable of a sexually repressed newlywed taking revenge on a doltish husband whom she discovers
seeks pleasures of the flesh through a mechanical servant. Caitlín R. Kiernan's "The Steam Dancer (1896)"
relates the desires of a woman rescued from death with bionic appendages who only feels truly whole as a
saloon dancer before an audience of opium addicts attentive to her body, but oblivious to her artistry. As
long as we're on the subject of mechanically enabled creatures, "The Cast Iron Kid" by Andrew Knighton
presents a Western gunfight in which the title character is undone not by a six-shooter, but by principles
of subatomic physics. "As Recorded on Brass Cylinders: Adagio for Two Dancers" by James L. Grant and Lisa
Matchev probably could have been recast as a "mainstream" SF story in which a pair of androids share the
troubling human emotions of love and loyalty; however, put in a steampunk context, it seems to me that
much more poignant, thanks to such passages as:
If you're looking for something more Sherlockian, no need to fret. Check out "The Strange Case of Mr.
Salad Monkey" by G.D. Falksen, which posits broadsheet publication as a Twitter forerunner, with dire
implications the protagonists can barely comprehend, and Daniel Abraham's "Balfour and Meriwether in the
Adventure of the Emperor Vengeance" in which two of her Majesty's special agents, as well as a comely
female amateur (there's that Steed/Peel thing again) battle ancient automations whose fate kick starts
the Industrial Revolution and modern civilization. The concluding paragraph is particularly affective.
Not everything is restricted to 19th century London, though. "The Mechanical Aviary of Emperor
Jalal-ud-din Muhammad Akbar" is another in a series of tales by Shweta Narayan that recast Indian myths
with mechanical beings. And the steampunk trappings of Jeffrey Ford's "Dr. Lash Remembers," original to
this volume, takes place in some phantasmagoria.
Publishing woes have resulted in the demise of a number of promising anthology series. Here's hoping this
particular series continues to pick up steam.
David Soyka is a former journalist and college teacher who writes the occasional short story and freelance article. He makes a living writing corporate marketing communications, which is a kind of fiction without the art. |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
If you find any errors, typos or anything else worth mentioning,
please send it to editor@sfsite.com.
Copyright © 1996-2014 SF Site All Rights Reserved Worldwide