Un Lun Dun | ||||||||
China Miéville | ||||||||
Del Rey, 425 pages | ||||||||
|
A review by Paul Kincaid
Un Lun Dun is described as a young adult novel, but it will be read with satisfaction by adult readers who will probably
remain blissfully unaware that it theoretically belongs in this category.
Miéville has always been a didactic writer, his novels about Bas Lag are crowded with lessons about community and commonality,
about class and tolerance, about our moral, political and social values. He is also a writer of bold colours and dramatic shapes,
his books crowded with the monstrous, the spectacular, the vivid. The way he writes for adults, therefore, is not a jot different
from the way he writes for children. And if the lessons most clearly on display in Un Lun Dun will stand us in good stead
when we are young and fresh, they are no less valuable when we are old and jaded. If the character we follow is a teenage girl
rather than someone older, it is no less easy to identify with her trials and resourcefulness, her fears and triumphs.
The lessons of Un Lun Dun are specifically and deliberately iconoclastic. Just as in his adult novels, Miéville
has raged against the complacent acceptance of the status quo, the failure to question authority, so here he rages against the
assumptions that guide our lives, the unquestioned rules laid down in the comforting fantasies normally prescribed for
children. Thus here we find the standard tropes that have bulked out so many simplistic quest fantasies: the unknowing hero
long prophesied as the saviour of the land; the sequence of tasks that must be completed in ascending order of difficulty;
the final battle between good and evil for the soul of the land. But each of these is blatantly and wittily subverted so
that, in the end, we have learned that any one of us can be the hero, any one of us can stand up against the forces ranged
against us, any one of us can defeat the villain. And the great villain is not Satan, this war between good and evil has
none of the supernatural religious overtones so beloved of lazy and unimaginative fantasists. The evil that must be
overcome is mankind's own creation, the despoilation of our environment.
We start in contemporary London, where teenage schoolgirl Zanna and her best friend Deeba seem to be the focus of a series of
strange events. Eventually these lead them through a crack between the worlds into a parallel city, UnLondon, where they
discover that Zanna is the Shwazzy, the Chosen One, destined to lead them to victory against the evil Smog. UnLondon is a
magnificent creation, as vivid, as full of spectacular invention, as New Crobuzon, which is hardly surprising since both
are avatars of London. UnLondon is the place that all the discards of our world seep through to and acquire a curious animation.
During the course of the novel, Deeba acquires an empty milk carton as a pet, we meet a diving suit filled with fish,
there are suburban houses that are also jungles, battles involving broken umbrellas, and more, all giving Miéville
the excuse for a dazzling display of puns and wordplay. But in their first confrontation with the bad guys, Zanna is put
out of action and the two girls retreat to our London.
It is Deeba, the sidekick, who then discovers a crucial secret that could be vital for the battle for UnLondon, and hence
makes the hazardous journey back. Once there, since the role of hero is vacant, she finds herself assuming it by default,
setting out upon the seven prescribed tasks to collect the seven essential tokens. But after the first part of her quest,
she realises that they just don't have time for the whole rigmarole, and arbitrarily skips the remaining quests except for
the last one which will give her the weapon to fight the Smog. Along the way her companions are killed while some of the
bad guys get away and all the fantasy traditions, so long set in stone, are upended.
Of course it is possible to read Un Lun Dun without consciously taking on board any of this subversion. It is a
colourful novel crammed with exciting incidents, dramatic confrontations, and Miéville's weird yet strangely
appealing monsters. There is more than enough story to grip any reader, young or old, but as a deliberate anti-fantasy
it is also one of the most intelligent and engaging works of the fantastic to appear in some time.
Paul Kincaid is the recipient of the SFRA's Thomas D. Clareson Award for Distinguished Service for 2006. He is the co-editor of The Arthur C. Clarke Award: A Critical Anthology. |
If you find any errors, typos or anything else worth mentioning,
please send it to editor@sfsite.com.
Copyright © 1996-2014 SF Site All Rights Reserved Worldwide