Reviews Logo
SearchHomeContents PageSite Map
Civil War
Stuart Moore
Multi-cast performance
GraphicAudio, 6 hours

Civil War
Stuart Moore
Stuart Moore has been a writer, a book editor, and an award-winning comics editor. His recent writing includes Civil War and Web of Spider-Man, which was featured in a half-page New York Times article. He is also a partner in Botfriend, a graphic novel packaging company.

Stuart Moore Website
ISFDB Bibliography

Past Feature Reviews
A review by Dale Darlage

Advertisement
Marvel's Civil War is a "reboot" of the Marvel universe. It is not a fundamental change like the Star Trek re-boot that came with the last movie. Spider-Man is still Spider-Man and Iron Man still flies around and tries to control everything through Stark Industries. But some minor characters are killed and groups like S.H.I.E.L.D. and The Avengers are forever changed.

This audiobook is a dramatization of the 2012 novelization of the rather extensive comic book series that made up Marvel Comics' Civil War. However, there are some substantial differences between the two story lines.

The story begins with a group of young superheroes called the New Warriors tracking down a group of supervillains in Stamford, Connecticut. They attempt to apprehend the villains and during the fight one of the villains causes himself to explode rather than be captured -- the bad guys appear to have been using illegal drugs just before the fight so this is a serious case of impaired judgment. The explosion is massive and kills more than 700 people, causing a public outcry against untrained, irresponsible masked vigilantes who cause more damage than the outlaws they apprehend.

Within days the federal government has responded with sweeping legislation (negotiated with the help of Tony Stark) that requires all "meta-humans" be registered, unmasked, trained and licensed by the federal government and become federal employees and serve in a federally regulated superhero team working through S.H.I.E.L.D. Each team will be assigned to a state. Meta-humans who fail to comply will be hunted down, arrested and incarcerated in a special prison without any sort of trial. They will be released only if they decided to comply.

This is not a new idea in superhero stories. The Dark Knight deals with a government that has had enough of superhero vigilantes as does The Incredibles, but Civil War creates its own distinct look at this concept.

Spider-Man comes out of the shadows and becomes the symbol of this new movement when he unmasks himself during a Tony Stark press conference. Soon, his life is a disaster as old enemies and the press harass him at home and he loses his job once his newspaper figures out he was faking his Spider-Man stories and pictures for all of those years.

Captain America decides that this new policy reminds him of the World War II era Japanese internment camps and there are some similarities. Imprisonment based on who you are, not what you have done. Young Japanese men could not leave the camps unless they agreed to fight for America in the army in Europe. Imprisoned superheroes cannot leave prison unless they agree to serve the federal government as meta-human police. Captain America becomes the leader of those that refuse to register, Tony Stark/Iron Man is the leader of the group that complies and a war of words quickly becomes a super-sized fight and not everyone survives. Spider-Man serves as the symbolic fulcrum of the argument, swinging back and forth between the two until he finally makes a decision.

    One of the best things about science fiction is its ability to take a current event topic and turn it on its head and still be able to continue the discussion. In this case, this book discusses a number of issues, including:
  • Group safety vs. individual freedom and another person's rights;
  • Negotiating away your rights in exchange for safety;
  • Cloning;
  • The coerced use of behavior-modification techniques;
  • How far can corporate information gathering go?;
  • Combined corporate/government power vs. the rights of the individual;
  • Do you support America because it is your home or because it protects your rights?

The conflict between Tony Stark and Captain America continues until it gets to the requisite climactic fight scene -- this is a superhero story, after all. Personally, I loved this story until the clunky ending where one side cedes to the other. It was all rather anti-climactic compared to the build-up and it just did not work very well considering the rhetoric and drama that filled the rest of the story.

If Marvel was looking to re-boot their universe, this book does that in a way that seems rather natural. No time traveling enemies destroying worlds or killing a superhero's parents. In this case, the politics of being a superhero gets in the way and changes everything.

I am a huge fan of the work that GraphicAudio has done over the years with its adaptations of DC Comics' graphic novels. They promise "A movie in your mind" and they have never failed to produce high quality audio dramas that sound like old-fashioned radio plays with better sound effects, special music and usually more than twenty actors, plus a narrator. The fight scenes are amazing and the sound effects are always top notch.

Two or three years ago, I was asked on a message board if GraphicAudio ever performed anything by Marvel Comics. I confidently said that they did not and probably never would because DC and Marvel are like Pepsi and Coke -- forever in conflict. I assumed Marvel would eventually decide to go with another publisher and that was that. Boy, am I glad that I was wrong. Marvel and GraphicAudio working together means that there will be twice the opportunities to let GraphicAudio do what they do best with superhero stories, especially if their first one from Marvel is any indication of what is to come.

Copyright © 2013 Dale Darlage

Dale Darlage is a public school teacher and a proud lifelong resident of the Hoosier state. He and his wife are also proud to have passed on a love of books to their children (and to the family dog that knows some books are quite tasty). His reviews on all sorts of books are posted at dwdsreviews.blogspot.com.


SearchContents PageSite MapContact UsCopyright

If you find any errors, typos or anything else worth mentioning, please send it to editor@sfsite.com.
Copyright © 1996-2014 SF Site All Rights Reserved Worldwide