| The Foresight War | ||||||
| Anthony G. Williams | ||||||
| Authors Online, 336 pages | ||||||
| A review by Nathan Brazil
Erlang has with him a couple of examples of twenty-first century technology, including a working laptop computer. At the
beginning, neither man knows of the other, but as events progress it becomes obvious to them that both sides have
the advantage of someone from the future. At the beginning, neither man knows of the other, but as events progress
it becomes obvious to them that both sides have the advantage of someone from the future. Erlang's main objective
is to minimise the horrendous loss of life in the WW II that he is familiar with. His method is to make sure the
British have meticulous advanced knowledge as to what technology should be fast tracked, how Germany was known to
have developed the war in his time, and what tactical mistakes should be avoided. The latter include such things
as persuading the British government not to declare war on Germany when the Nazis annex Poland.
Meanwhile, in pre-war Germany, Herrman has a different agenda. His personal experience of
growing up in East Germany means that his main priority is to ensure that the German
war against Russia is won.
Famous names from WWII crop up as regular characters, including main players Churchill, Hitler, and Rommel. Others,
such as Roosevelt and Stalin, are spoken about but not seen in person. The historical cast stay true to
character, just as history has portrayed them. This puts Konrad Herrman at a disadvantage, as he's constantly
trying to deal with Nazi leaders whose fanaticism borders on mental illness. Don Erlang mostly gets his own way,
but is frustrated to find that his original hope to avoid war entirely is unfeasible, as history up to that point
makes conflict inevitable. What follows is a fast paced, easy to read story, heavy with technical detail and light
on dialogue. Event after event shows the result of the time travellers influence on their leaders. The author has
a precise, factually biased style of writing that explains what's necessary, but rarely goes more than a few steps
beyond. The impression given, perhaps intentionally, is of a series of snapshots scattered between the larger,
set piece encounters with alternate history. Among the latter is a different version of Pearl Harbor.
On the negative side, I was puzzled to find some of the leading characters and events from standard history were absent.
For example, Martin Bormann, who according to my Encyclopaedia of the Third Reich was the most important man next to the
Fuehrer during the declining days of the war, does not appear. Another unexplained AWOL is Rudolf Hess, deputy
to the Fuehrer, who at one time was Hitler's appointed successor to Goering. Nor is there any clear view as to
whether the Nazis were implementing their Final Solution, or what became of the projects being developed under
the Wunderwaffen program, other than V1 and V2 rockets. Then there's the issue of what impact Erlang's modern PC
would actually have had. Mention is made of its usefulness to the British code breakers, but to me its presence
and potential as an agent of change seemed underplayed. However, none of these issues get in the way of the story,
or make it any less enjoyable. The one serious flaw is a lack of characterisation, in particular with Erlang and
Herrman, the time travellers. Neither of them ever question how they came to slip through time, if there might be
a way back, or what has become of the future without them.
Both spend large amounts of the story being little more than walking text books, which at times left me feeling
as if I was reading half a book. It was the half containing precise technical detail and accurate historical
possibilities. The missing half, was the pure flight of imagination present in the best fictional stories,
including characters who never lived but seem real. In future titles, I would hope that the author spends more
time developing the skills of a novelist, or perhaps works in conjunction with someone whose primary talent is
writing fiction. It would be a formidable combination.
In summary, The Foresight War is a highly plausible alternate take on history, which reads more like an
alternate historical record, than a story set in another timeline.
|
||||||
|
|
If you find any errors, typos or anything else worth mentioning,
please send it to editor@sfsite.com.
Copyright © 1996-2013 SF Site All Rights Reserved Worldwide