David Brin's Out of Time: Yanked! | |||||||||
Nancy Kress | |||||||||
Avon EOS Books, 256 pages | |||||||||
|
A review by Rich Horton
The 24th century humans (here it comes) don't have the "grit" anymore
to deal with hostile aliens. So they use the time travel feature to grab humans from the
violent preceding centuries to supply the requisite "grit." The final rather silly gimmick
is that only humans younger than about 17 can travel in either time or space. Voila! Teen
heroes. Just what a YA series needs!
I'm all for YA SF books. I certainly read my share when I was young, and I still read them
now. That last clause reveals a secret: the good YA books are YA only in that Young Adults are
featured as heroes. But the books themselves should be fun for adults to read as well. The setup
for this series seems laboured and silly to me, with both the tired cliché of the people of the
violent past (that is to say, now) having more "grit" than the pacifist folks of the future;
and with a very strained gimmick to restrict the action to teen heroes. This isn't a good sign, but
on the other hand, the series' creator has a promising name: David Brin; and the author of the
first book is a very fine writer: Nancy Kress. So let's give it a try.
Yanked! features two main characters from the present day.
Jason Ramsay is a talented basketball player from New York City. Jason is intelligent
and a natural leader, but he seems to be risking his future by his undisciplined approach
both to basketball and school. Sharon Myers is a shy, intelligent girl in a small town. Her
future is threatened by her drunken single mother, and her need to care for her shiftless sister's
child. The future folks yank Sharon and Jason, along with Robbie, a thief from Regency England,
and Jofrid, a spirited 14-year-old from 10th-century Iceland, in order to form a team which
will go to a planet where a group of future children has been marooned, and where the hostile
Panurish, three-eyed aliens, are threatening the marooned children in order to try to find
a message from the Gift Givers. By mistake, Sharon's niece Tara is yanked to the future
along with Sharon.
The main action is set on the new planet, Jump. The children struggle to form a team,
overcoming individual dislikes and cultural problems. Of course, each of them has critical
contributions to make: Jason's leadership and imagination, Jofrid's knowledge of surviving
in a non-technological society, Sharon's cleverness and her love of her niece, Robbie's thieving
skills.
The mystery of how to deal with the Panurish is solved in a somewhat clichéd fashion,
though the mystery of the hidden message is solved in a fairly satisfactory way. But while
there are occasional amusing passages, including Jason's idea for distracting the Panurish,
and his various attempts to organize the kids from different eras into athletic teams, most of
the story unfolds in a predictable way, with predictable lessons. The Panurish aren't very
interesting or convincing aliens, and the planet Jump isn't very interesting either. The
brief glimpses of the utopian future Earth society are slightly more interesting.
The key to almost any involving story is living characters, and Yanked! doesn't
really deliver on this level either. I was thrown by details in Jason's case: for instance,
he is shown dreaming of making a spectacular dunk, just like "Kareem or Larry."
Unfortunately, Larry Bird never dunked, and Kareem Abdul Jabbar was hardly known for
spectacular dunks. Sharon is presented with earnestness but nothing much else. Jofrid is
predictably too 20th-century in her attitudes, though she's engaging enough. Robbie is
perhaps presented best, but I couldn't get inside him. Maybe the most interesting character
of all was the future robot, unconvincingly named Da Vinci.
Another key for SF is what might
be called living ideas, and Nancy Kress has always been good at presenting and following
up on neat ideas. But this story completely lacks any really compelling Science Fictional ideas, and
Kress' effort seems perfunctory.
I'll keep hoping for good new YA SF, but this book isn't it, and I can't be very
optimistic about this series, either. All in all, a disappointing attempt from two
very fine Science Fiction talents.
Rich Horton is an eclectic reader in and out of the SF and fantasy genres. He's been reading SF since before the Golden Age (that is, since before he was 13). Born in Naperville, IL, he lives and works (as a Software Engineer for the proverbial Major Aerospace Company) in St. Louis area and is a regular contributor to Tangent. Stop by his website at http://www.sff.net/people/richard.horton. |
If you find any errors, typos or anything else worth mentioning,
please send it to editor@sfsite.com.
Copyright © 1996-2014 SF Site All Rights Reserved Worldwide