Medalon: Book One of the Hythrun Chronicles | |||||
Jennifer Fallon | |||||
Tor, 428 pages | |||||
A review by Alma A. Hromic
In Australia, Medalon was the opening salvo of what is known as The Demon Child Trilogy. It is this
Demon Child with whom this particular segment of the series is concerned -- a being born of a union between a human woman and a
king of the Harshini, a semi-mythical elf-like magical race with demon-taming potential. Keeping to true fantasy tropes, this
lost child has no inkling of her true identity as the book opens -- and neither, apparently, has the only other half-Harshini
character, Brak, sent by the rest of the Harshini and the Gods (who have a somewhat disconcerting ability to waltz in and out
of human senses) to seek the demon child and bring it back to the Harshini Sanctuary where there is a large and somewhat fraught
destiny waiting.
This is the first book of a series, and perhaps it is to be expected that it raises more questions than it wants to answer just
yet -- but I did find myself a little hazy on just how one half-Harshini character differed from the other and why Brak didn't have
at least the potential for being the demon child himself. Add to that his somewhat blundering attempts to locate that child, only
to discover that her identity and whereabouts had more or less been known to the Gods all along, and Brak's role in the storyline
becomes a little moot. Although I get the distinct sense that there are secrets in his past which still have a role to play in the
future, I did have to wonder what his purpose was in the current dramatic developments. His Gods are less than helpful when he
himself confronts them with this issue -- they tell him, in a fine example of god-like non-sequitur which leaves itself open to a
hundred interpretations, that the weapon that was the demon child had to be "tempered" before it was used, therefore implying
that Brak's presence was essential not in the discovery of the child in question but in her preparation for what lies in
store for her.
The demon child herself, R'Shiel, is a wonderful protagonist -- and I would guess more "tempering" is in store for her in the books
to come. As a fellow writer of fantasy, I think I share with Jennifer Fallon the distinct danger that the characters we bring to
life and then put through their own special hells in order to be "tempered" enough for our purposes might lie in wait for us in
some lonely alley on some dark night with thoughts of revenge; it is unfortunate that we have taught so many of those characters
to be so lethal with weapons of every shape and form. I think an opportunity has been missed in Medalon, where such
proficiency with weapons and strange powers is concerned, in the somewhat perfunctory account of R'Shiel's night of coming to
terms with her new identity as the demon child, and the kind of havoc that can wreak. There's a throwaway sentence in there
somewhere of a stray lightning bolt flung by R'Shiel's untrained mind which incinerates an unlucky ship that happened to be in
the wrong place at the wrong time -- I would have loved to have been "shown" that scene (and R'Shiel's reaction to it) in more detail.
If I have quibbles, they're minor. It is a moot point, for instance, whether Jennifer Fallon ever encountered a particularly odd
party game called Jenga before she called her Lord Defender that, but I have, and it tends to trip me up every time he steps out
onto center stage -- she is, however, in august company with this kind of thing, and Lord Defender Palin Jenga is no worse than a
spare-part King called Aileron in Guy Gavriel Kay's Fionavar trilogy). I do have to take issue with Jennifer
Fallon's assertion, right at the end of the book, that R'Shiel "finally knew who she was." No, she didn't. She finally knew what
she was, which is a horse of a very different colour. Learning who she is will take her the rest of her life, as such lessons
do with most of us out here in real life.
Medalon is a deep draught from the well of classic High Fantasy -- and there are many readers out there waiting for their
thirst to be quenched. I predict that Fallon will be a household name very soon, and not just Down Under.
Alma A. Hromic, addicted (in random order) to coffee, chocolate and books, has a constant and chronic problem of "too many books, not enough bookshelves". When not collecting more books and avidly reading them (with a cup of coffee at hand), she keeps busy writing her own. Following her successful two-volume fantasy series, Changer of Days, her latest novel, Jin-shei, is due out from Harper San Francisco in the spring of 2004. |
If you find any errors, typos or anything else worth mentioning,
please send it to editor@sfsite.com.
Copyright © 1996-2014 SF Site All Rights Reserved Worldwide