| Mistral's Kiss | ||||||||
| Laurel K. Hamilton | ||||||||
| Ballantine, 212 pages | ||||||||
|
A review by Nathan Brazil
This time around, the man who literally makes the earth move
is Mistral, a sadistically inclined fey. Mistral, enjoys biting Meredith's breasts, and there are tens of pages of fairly graphic
near porn, before developments that might be expected in a traditional dark fantasy novel occur. Even then the major event,
involving Sholto, King of the Sluagh, culminates with another bout of sex. In some ways, this over-abundance worked like
aversion therapy. The more Meredith's carnal activities were described in sticky detail, the less attention I
paid. Instead, I found myself flicking on a few pages, in an effort to find the story, which at that point I hoped was still in there.
The immense frustration for readers who find enough sex in the real world, is that
Laurell K. Hamilton can easily produce evocative imagery well
within the wide parameters of the genre in which the Meredith Gentry series is placed. Yet time after time she chooses to have
her lead character explore increasingly violent sexual fantasies, often at the expense of storytelling. As with previous titles,
the characters and plot elements promise much, only to shy away from the more interesting questions.
Hamilton plays at being Nancy Friday, and the effect is to reduce most of the Sidhe, Goblins and Sluagh, to characters who seem to
be there more for their dangly bits, than for anything magical. Meredith Gentry -- and I'm sure Hamilton herself -- would
argue that the dangly bits are magical, but I could not shake the feeling that readers in agreement with them are mostly
frustrated housewives or pubescent teenagers.
Sitting in the opposite corner, are the folk who would like to know much more about fine characters such as Andais, Doyle,
Killing Frost, Sholto, and the history of the Fey in America. But they get precious little, as serious development flounders
when the characters spend so much of their time hanging around in the hope of being next between Meredith's legs.
It isn't erotic. It isn't titillating. It isn't even innovative.
I finished Mistral's Kiss feeling somewhat swindled. I'd kept faith that the undoubted literary talent that Hamilton
possesses would mean the series eventually returned to its roots. Instead, what I got was another load of fey sexploitation,
masquerading as fantasy. If Hamilton wants to explore sexual themes at such length, no problem, let her write a full on
erotic novel, and see if that is a bestseller. But for me, this was the novel that finally made me give up on the series,
and on Hamilton as a writer of magically based fantasy works. Each to our own, but I don't want to read another word
about breast biting, blow-jobs, multiple orgasms or thrusting bodies. Enough is enough.
|
|||||||
|
|
If you find any errors, typos or anything else worth mentioning,
please send it to editor@sfsite.com.
Copyright © 1996-2013 SF Site All Rights Reserved Worldwide