| The Sun, the Genome, and the Internet -- Tools of Scientific Revolutions | ||||||||||
| Freeman J. Dyson | ||||||||||
| Oxford Books, 124 pages | ||||||||||
|
A review by Peter D. Tillman
For example, he presents the hope of engineering "trees that convert sunlight
to liquid fuel and deliver the fuel directly... to underground pipelines." A neat solution to
declining oil reserves, if it works. Dyson cheerfully admits his record as a prophet is mixed,
but "it is better to be wrong than to be vague."
Fresh and unexpected insights are a frequent pleasure in this and other Dyson books. For
instance, he describes his mother and aunts -- prosperous British matrons all -- who, in the
interval between the World Wars, accomplished such things as opening a birth-control clinic,
managing a large hospital, winning an Olympic medal, and pioneering aviation in
Africa -- "it was considered normal at the time for middle-class women to do something
spectacular." They were able to do this only with the support of a large servant class. The
introduction of labour-saving appliances helped to emancipate the servants, but left
middle-class women less free than before, a general pattern, says Dyson: "the burdens of
equalization fall disproportionately on women."
Dyson is a lifelong space enthusiast, though things haven't gone that well lately for space
fans: "we look at the bewildered cosmonauts struggling to survive in the Mir space station.
Obviously they are not going anywhere except, if they are lucky, down." But in the long term,
prospects are brighter, as we await the finding of a cheap way up and out of the gravity well (another
enduring Dyson insight). He reports recent successful tests of a laser-launcher and a
"ram accelerator," the latter a proposed 750-foot gas-gun -- and a direct descendent of
Jules Verne's cannon-launched spacecraft in From the Earth to the Moon (1865). As in all
cheap launch methods, the trick is to keep the fuel on the ground, not in the spacecraft. With
cheap spaceflight, people will spread out into the solar system and
beyond. Why? "Because it is there" -- some folks just have itchy feet. Others will belong to
unpopular religions, or be on the run, or... any of the countless other things that have always motivated emigrants.
Dyson, unusually for a theoretician, has always been more "tinker than thinker." He cites
Thomas Kuhn's classic Structure of Scientific Revolutions (1962, revised edition 1970) as an
example of a fellow-physicist with the opposite bent, emphasizing ideas over things. Of course,
both are important; but some of Kuhn's followers put forward the idea that science is about
power struggles, not new ideas. Dyson once upbraided Kuhn about this at a conference. Kuhn
reacted angrily: "One thing you have to understand. I am not a Kuhnian!"
Freeman Dyson is my favourite scientist-writer. I know of no one else who combines his clarity
of thought, graceful use of language, big ideas expressed modestly, and sense of history. If
you haven't yet read Dyson, The Sun, the Genome, and the Internet would be a fine place to start.
Pete Tillman has been reading SF for better than 40 years now. He reviews SF -- and other books -- for Usenet, "Under the Covers", Infinity-Plus, Dark Planet, and SF Site. He's a mineral exploration geologist based in Arizona. More of his reviews are posted at www.silcom.com/~manatee/reviewer.html#tillman . | |||||||||
|
|
If you find any errors, typos or other stuff worth mentioning,
please send it to editor@sfsite.com.
Copyright © 1996-2013 SF Site All Rights Reserved Worldwide
Worldwide