| Vassal of El | ||||||||
| Gloria Oliver | ||||||||
| Zumaya Publications, 285 pages | ||||||||
|
A review by Georges T. Dodds
While Vassal of El, the author's second published novel isn't mired in clichés, and the story is clearly and competently
described, it isn't however terribly original, and certain elements of the story certainly don't enhance its plausibility. For example,
when Torren returns with the teenage Larana to her home, burned to the ground by those seeking her, and she runs into the ruins to discover
her adoptive parents burnt to death, to the point where "pieces of the corpses had come away with [the debris]" she is initially in shock,
virtually unconscious of his presence, but within minutes she is discussing local geography with him, and within a few days she appears to
have completely forgotten these highly traumatic events. Certainly she in no way exhibits any psychological disorders resulting from
post-traumatic stress. Within days, she is capable of bargaining for lodging and taking care of animals, without the least
hesitancy. Certainly Torren is far more believable as the archetype of the man with a past who has shut himself out to women.
The story of a seemingly lower caste outsider who enters and saves an upper caste society from itself is nothing new (e.g. Thomas
Temple Hoyne's 1934 Intrigue on the Upper Level), but here the story is much more one of mystery and intrigue than one of
social commentary, particularly as Flyer society is little described, beyond very broad strokes. Similarly, there is no description
of how it feels to be a Flyer, as opposed to a Lander, what does such an ability bring to the life experience of a Flyer? Edmond
Hamilton's "He That Hath Wings" (Weird Tales, July 1938) is perhaps the best story to explore this experience. As for
any mystery regarding the bad seed among the Flyers, what mystery is there? Very little: as the traitor amongst the Flyers is
obvious early on with his "knowing smiles" and the fact that Larana/Aen shivers when in his close proximity -- amongst other clues.
Stories of winged humans date back to Daedalus and Icarus, but have made numerous appearances in fantasy literature, particularly
in lost race tales, from Robert Paltock's The Life and Adventures of Peter Wilkins (1751) set in Antarctica to Stanton
Coblentz's When Birds Fly South (1945) set in central Asia. Unlike these works, the Flyer's ability to fly is not exploited,
either in terms of what they are physically capable or of any symbolism. Certainly the sense of wonder and desire that Paltock's
and Coblentz's male protagonists exhibit before winged humanoids, is not matched by the Landers of Vassal of El, rather the
Landers are mostly jealous and resentful of the Flyers. Even if Vassal of El's original title was Wings of Angels, there's
very little of an angelic nature in the Flyers, a number of them being rather elitist not to say outright racist towards the Landers
or "grubs." What is perhaps interesting is the parallels one might draw between the character of Larana/Ael, a wingless Flyer, and
the flying women whose wings are clipped by men in the early (1914) feminist lost race novel Angel Island by
Inez Haynes Gillmore (both authors coincidentally having been born
in Iberian cultures, Oliver in Puerto Rico and Gillmore in Brasil), but I'll leave that to those better versed in such studies.
For an entertaining, don't ask too many questions read, Vassal of El delivers, and is suitable for readers young and old,
which for a new author like Oliver is already a significant attainment. However, if you want your fantasy with something below the
surface, perhaps some socio-political commentary, then look elsewhere.
Georges Dodds is a research scientist in vegetable crop physiology, who for close to 25 years has read and collected close to 2000 titles of predominantly pre-1950 science-fiction and fantasy, both in English and French. He writes columns on early imaginative literature for WARP, the newsletter/fanzine of the Montreal Science Fiction and Fantasy Association and maintains a site reflecting his tastes in imaginative literature. |
|||||||
|
|
If you find any errors, typos or anything else worth mentioning,
please send it to editor@sfsite.com.
Copyright © 1996-2013 SF Site All Rights Reserved Worldwide