Aurealis #32 | |||||
A review by Matthew Cheney
The non-fiction is, overall, stronger than the fiction, with good interviews with HarperCollins editor Stephanie Smith, literary agent
Selwa Anthony, and writer Lynn Flewelling. There are articles on computer games and war games, an article titled "Why is the Most
Popular Australian SF Not Published in Australia," the scientific possibilities of enhancing human evolution, and even a thoughtful
essay on gun control. The magazine often reads as if it is aimed at aspiring writers who are just discovering the world of
publishing. The editorial in this issue, for instance, lays out editor Keith Stevenson's criteria for selecting fiction for
Aurealis, with specific examples from past issues of the magazine.
Unfortunately, issue 32 does not contain much fiction that lives up to the ideas Stevenson puts forth in his editorial. While he
calls for original ideas and "using the tropes in a new way," none of the six stories struck me as being particularly original or
new, and few of them were compelling. There is much awkward dialogue, plodding narrative, dully familiar settings, and predictable
plot twists. The writers all may be capable of excellent work, but the work on display here is not particularly distinguished.
"The Gift of Hindsight" by Paul Haines is one of the better stories, a fantasy story of a roguish wanderer who receives a gift that
allows him to turn back time, with unexpected consequences. It's a diverting story, but one that has been told similarly and much
better by many other writers.
"Line of Defence" by Stephen Dedman is considerably less effective, a clunkingly obvious science fiction story. Sue Isle's "Dog Years"
contains some good writing and good attempts at character, particularly the character of a man whose body ages much slower than
other people's do, but the story itself needed either to be pruned or expanded -- it is stuck at a length that doesn't allow some
of the most interesting ideas and characters to develop convincingly, but is long enough to have some dull spots. "Garments of
the Dead" by Tansy Rayner Roberts manages to turn the story of Herakles and his wives from grand tragedy to pathetic
psychodrama. There is some competent plotting in Richard Harland's "Catabolic Magic," and the story is set in a fantasy world
that could be quite interesting with more development, but the characters are too thin to create interest in their actions and the
background world is not vivid enough to sustain the story.
The sixth piece of fiction, "The Lamb" by Brendan Duffy, is probably the best of the lot, a mildly amusing UFO story. Most of the
components of the story have been used in hundreds of other such tales, but there's a dry wit to the writing that makes its
chronicle of alien abduction bearable.
Matthew Cheney teaches at the New Hampton School and has published in English Journal, Failbetter.com, Ideomancer, and Locus, among other places. He writes regularly about science fiction on his weblog, The Mumpsimus. |
If you find any errors, typos or anything else worth mentioning,
please send it to editor@sfsite.com.
Copyright © 1996-2014 SF Site All Rights Reserved Worldwide