Greatest Uncommon Denominator #5, Winter 2009 | |||||
A review by Seamus Sweeney
Greatest Uncommon Denominator #5 is a mix of
prose, poetry, fiction, fact, art, comics and even drama. The good folks at GUD proclaim
on their site to be unconstrained by genre or form -- bringing the world sci-fi for the literary crowd and
literary stuff for the sci-fi crowd. The dichotomy between sci-fi and "literature" is of course a false one,
but it does reflect perhaps a divergence of interests among groups of readers who ultimately value originality
and literary quality. One could crudely put it that some readers value originality of ideas and settings over
literary craft per se, while others prefer originality and quality of literary expression. Curating an anthology
that goes even some way to satisfying these different preferences is quite a task.
I enjoyed the very first piece, Rose Lemberg's "Imperfect Verse," with its evocation of Norse myth combined with
an earthiness and forward momentum. For me, it possessed a winning blend of high-register epic discourse and
fleshy concerns. Other stories that were particular highlights for me were Paul Hogan's casually
fantastic "The Pearl Diver With The Gold Chain" and Isabel Cooper Kunkle's "Aftermath." Hogan, whose bio informs
us is 82 years old, spent time in the Merchant Marine in WWII and the Eleventh Airborne Division during
the Korean War, and has designed and built over four hundred playgrounds, contributes a particularly engaging
tale of a happily rootless wanderer who discovers an odd power in a mundane place.
On the comics front, we have Sydney Padua's witty take on Ada Lovelace and Charles Babbage in "Ada Lovelace:
The Origin!,"" and Joseph Calabrese and Harsho Mohan Chattoraj's "Gunga Din," a rendering of the Kipling ballad that
firmly nails it as a sweaty, bloody, thirsty war story. "Gunga Din" is a short-spinoff of Calabrese and
Chattoraj's longer comic Her Majesty's Bulldog Brigade, which I will be keeping an eye out for. We also have
a funny Shakespearean parody from Tristan D'Agosta, "Sweet Melodrama," which I would love to see actually
performed. Non-fiction wise, we have Paul Spinrad's "Prophet of Menlo Park," about the personal computing
pioneer Paul Engelbart.
An anthology such as this will have something for everyone, and also inevitably not everything will meet with
everyone's approval. Some of the stories were a little too much post-apocalyptic cliché for my liking. Most
of the poetry left me largely cold both intellectually and emotionally, and left no lasting impression. However
my favourite piece of any kind in Greatest Uncommon Denominator #5
is Zac Carter's poem "desideratum" -- a warm, poignant account of a session
playing Risk that evokes much more.
Overall, Greatest Uncommon Denominator lives up to its promise as a high-quality forum for new voices.
Seamus Sweeney is a freelance writer and medical graduate from Ireland. He has written stories and other pieces for the website Nthposition.com and other publications. He is the winner of the 2010 Molly Keane Prize. He has also written academic articles as Seamus Mac Suibhne. |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
If you find any errors, typos or anything else worth mentioning,
please send it to editor@sfsite.com.
Copyright © 1996-2014 SF Site All Rights Reserved Worldwide