The Rivers of War | ||||||||
Eric Flint | ||||||||
Del Rey, 491 pages | ||||||||
|
A review by Peter D. Tillman
Flint's aim in this first of a new series is to construct a plausible Native Nation on America's western frontier,
from the Cherokees and the other four Civilized Tribes who were dumped into Indian Territory (now eastern Oklahoma) in
the first half of the 19th century, with unhappy results in our timeline (though they're doing OK now). Flint makes it
clear that, with the number of European immigrants pouring into the Southeast, the tribes were going to lose their
land, one way or another.
He's trying for a less-horrible eviction than the Trail of Tears. What if the Tribes moved 'voluntarily,' with their
cultures more or less intact, and developed a hybrid culture that would affect America for the good? I'll be following the
progress of this what-might-have-been saga with interest -- particularly since my Scots-Irish ancestors helped make
this history, and picked up a little Cherokee blood en route.
I came away from The Rivers of War with a more three-dimensional mental portrait of Andrew Jackson, a
major character here, and whom I'd previously filed under "boorish rabble-rouser." He looks much better (or at least
more complex) in Flint's portrayal. Most of his characters were historical figures (including Sam Houston, a
protagonist), though Flint cheerfully admits to fleshing-out the less well-known ones to fit his story. His battle
scenes are unflinching, and may be too graphic for some. But Flint seems to have an unusually good understanding
of the principles of warfare. And you won't be surprised to learn that Flint was once a candidate for a Ph.D. in history.
Now, this is alternate history, but I don't think I'll spoil your fun by letting on that Flint has stuck pretty close
to real history, so far anyway. And he's dished up an excellent historical novel here -- entertaining,
informative, fast-moving, action-packed. Lots of blood and gore (fair warning). I read it in two sittings and liked it a lot.
The Rivers of War is Flint's best novel to date -- he's gotten better in the craft of writing, characterization,
depth of research -- heck, all the writerly virtues I can think of. Most importantly, he's a helluva storyteller. Highly
recommended.
If you would like further fictional exploration of Cherokee history, I strongly recommend Larry McMurtry's very
fine Zeke and Ned, set in mid-19th century Oklahoma, after their forced resettlement. A crackerjack, underrated
historical novel.
Pete Tillman has been reading SF for better than 40 years now. He reviews SF -- and other books -- for Amazon, Infinity-Plus, SF Site, and others. He's a mineral exploration geologist based in Arizona. Google "Peter D. Tillman" +review for many more of Pete's reviews. |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
If you find any errors, typos or other stuff worth mentioning,
please send it to editor@sfsite.com.
Copyright © 1996-2014 SF Site All Rights Reserved Worldwide