Phases of the Moon: Stories of Six Decades | ||||||||
Robert Silverberg | ||||||||
Subterranean Press, 630 pages | ||||||||
|
A review by Jayme Lynn Blaschke
Except, of course, when that writer is Robert Silverberg. Phases of the Moon reads not so
much like a single author collection, but rather an anthology giving a historical overview of the
evolution of the genre spanning six decades. Every story here could have a different author's
name on it, and I wouldn't blink twice. The ease at which Silverberg shifts perspective and
approach, changes the very rhythm of his sentences, the selection of words is nothing short of
amazing. Each story reads as if it sprang from a different mind, flowed from unrelated fingers
onto pages separated by not only miles, but lifetimes. As if that wasn't accomplishment enough,
these "other writers" who just happen to share the Robert Silverberg moniker, produce stories
that are not merely good, but relentlessly good. Many authors work a lifetime striving to
reach a degree of excellence in there work, but in Phases of the Moon Silverberg
cherry-picks -- count 'em -- 23 stories that fit the bill. The mind boggles.
Anyone who has read any amount of science fiction or fantasy at all should recognize at least a
few of the stories collected here. There's a plethora of Hugo and Nebula award-winners, and
more that have been reprinted multiple times. I, myself, was more than familiar with a handful.
"Good News from the Vatican," a light hearted classic about the first robotic pope, is one that I
studied in literature class at Texas A&M University back in the 80s. "Sailing to Byzantium" was
immensely powerful the first time I read it, and I marveled at the creativity that not only
conceived of "Enter a Soldier. Later: Enter Another" but was able to pull it off so confidently.
Those -- along with some others -- I knew. No surprises there. It's the other stories in this
book that bowled me over this time.
"The Pope of the Chimps" is grounded in reality so firmly it almost isn't genre at all. If you
consider the extensive sign language vocabulary of Koko the famous gorilla, then the tale shifts
from the realm of disturbingly plausible to frighteningly probable. Which, naturally enough, raises
theological questions that extend beyond the story's scope, that if lower animals voluntarily and
willfully worship in the Judeo-Christian tradition, would they then be entitled to eternal souls?
"Hunters in the Forest" starts off simply enough as a riff on Ray Bradbury's classic "A Sound of
Thunder," but instead of ripples through time, Silverberg sets off devastating emotional ripples
that are amazingly cruel and profoundly satisfying. "To See the Invisible Man" is an engrossing
character study touching on many aspects of crime, punishment and the need for social contact.
One of my favorites in the collection is the final story collected here: "With Caesar in the
Underworld." This deft piece of alternate history uncoils itself casually, following the days of a
minor Roman official and the youngest son of the infirm emperor as they play host to an
ambassador from the Byzantine Empire. For entertainment, they travel deep in the subterranean
world that exists beneath the famed Seven Hills, vaults and caverns built over the course of
centuries that now host all manner of bizarre bazaars and peculiar entertainments. The narrative
dispenses with plot and instead assembles itself as something of a series of day-in-the-life
sequences that flow seamlessly together. Certain foreshadowed touchstones come and go, and the
randomness of real life forces itself into the spotlight more often than not. Ultimately, this is a
story not about a great empire in decline, but of those individuals who may or may not be
significant that comprise that very empire. The narrative concludes the only way it could -- a
conclusion impossible to see coming, but one that's unsurprising -- and the story gels as a cohesive
whole.
The only pieces that don't entirely measure up are the four stories that represent Silverberg's
output in the 50s -- and to be fair, anything from that era would suffer in comparison to his later
work. On their own, they are all solid stories, showing a clever and diverse mind at work. Against
any other short fiction from that same decade, they more than hold their own. But when placed
side-by-side with the other selections in this collection, the tremendous leap Silverberg's skill in
crafting words made during the early years of the 60s is driven home convincingly. And again,
each stands apart from the others, distinctive in style and approach. I, for one, am appreciative of
their inclusion.
The introductions accompanying the individual stories are a welcome touch as well, setting
context for the period and atmosphere the stories were written in. The evolution of "Born with
the Dead" is a particularly poignant one, tracing how a crumbling marriage and social turmoil
came together with death themes he'd been working on to produce the story which, ultimately,
served as the centerpiece of a special, unexpected Robert Silverberg issue of The Magazine of
Fantasy and Science Fiction. This type of information is the living, breathing history of the
genre. If it isn't recorded, it is lost forever. That Silverberg took the time and effort to set it to
paper, thus ensuring a little bit of history is passed on to posterity... well, that deserves special
praise. The only real negative in these introductions are the many times Silverberg recalls the
self-doubt that dogged him at times, the belief that the genre had passed him by and that his particular
brand of creativity was no longer of interest to the reading masses. To which current readers may
well feel the urge to reach back through the decades, give his younger self a good shaking and
shout, "You're Robert Silverberg for crying out loud! Write!"
So is Phases of the Moon a good investment? Only if you happen to like brilliant, gripping
prose that challenges as well as entertains. It may not be the best collection ever, but for my
money it's the best collection of the year. Careers that produce six decades' worth of wonder
don't come around all that often, so it's best to savor them when the opportunity arises.
Jayme Lynn Blaschke writes science fiction and fantasy as well as related non-fiction. A collection of his interviews, Voices of Vision: Creators of Science Fiction and Fantasy Speak, is forthcoming from the University of Nebraska Press and he also serves as fiction editor for RevolutionSF.com. His web log can be found at jlbgibberish.blogspot.com |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
If you find any errors, typos or anything else worth mentioning,
please send it to editor@sfsite.com.
Copyright © 1996-2014 SF Site All Rights Reserved Worldwide