Winterfair Gifts | |||||
Lois McMaster Bujold | |||||
Narrated by Grover Gardner, unabridged | |||||
Blackstone Audio, 2 hours, 32 minutes | |||||
A review by Nicki Gerlach
Miles details his most junior armsman, Roic, to be Taura's guide around Vorbarr Sultana; Miles knows this may well
be Taura's last chance to see Barrayar, given the shortened lifespan that comes part and parcel with her engineered
enhancements, and he wants the trip to be a pleasant one. Roic is a quintessential small-town boy, although
his initial wariness of Taura begins to dissipate as he gets to know her. However, one casual remark about
genetic engineering (in reference to the butterbugs of A Civil Campaign) shatters their growing
connection. Meanwhile, it seems as though someone is plotting to stop Miles and Ekaterin's wedding, and only
Taura, with Roic's help, will be able to save them.
Unusually for the Vorkosigan Saga, Winterfair Gifts is narrated entirely from the point-of-view
of a minor character -- an extremely minor character, if truth be told. I don't remember Armsman Roic having more
than five lines in A Civil Campaign, but he's thrust into the spotlight in Winterfair Gifts, and
he acquits himself quite well.
What surprised me most about this story was how effective it was at breaking my heart on behalf of characters
other than Miles. The Vorkosigans have been around for so many books that they feel like family, so it's no
surprise that my heart breaks on Miles's behalf roughly once per novel. Taura's had much less screen time,
but Lois McMaster Bujold is so deft with her characterizations that there were several times in the two and a half hours
of this book that I found myself going "Oh, please, no, don't do that to her; hasn't she been through
enough?" It all wraps up to a satisfying conclusion, but Bujold manages to wring a lot of drama and a lot
of emotion out of 71 pages of text.
While Winterfair Gifts was originally published in an anthology of fantasy and sci-fi love stories, I
don't know how well it fared with a reader unfamiliar with the Vorkosigan Saga. The basic plot
is straightforward enough, but so many nuances and details would be lost without knowing these characters and
their backgrounds. For example, while the general implications of Ellie Quinn's wedding present of a cat
blanket is explained within the confines of the story, I don't think that someone who hadn't read
both Brothers in Arms and Memory would really grasp how sharply double-edged that present is.
Within the context of the broader series, however, it's an engaging little story. I do wish the solution
to the mystery had been developed a little more; as it is it feels almost like an afterthought. But even
so, I really enjoyed listening to it -- Grover Gardner does a wonderful job with the narration, as usual -- and
it made a nice cap to Miles's and Ekaterin's romance of the past two books.
Nicki Gerlach is a mad scientist by day and an avid reader the rest of the time. More of her book reviews can be found at her blog, fyreflybooks.wordpress.com/. |
If you find any errors, typos or anything else worth mentioning,
please send it to editor@sfsite.com.
Copyright © 1996-2014 SF Site All Rights Reserved Worldwide