| Patient Zero | The Dragon Factory | |
| Jonathan Maberry | Jonathan Maberry | |
| St. Martin's Griffin, 421 pages | Gollancz / St. Martin's Griffin, 486 / 496 pages |
| A review by John Enzinas
Then it was my turn. I decided, sensibly enough, to start with the first book. It was awesome. A tightly written
Clancyesque techno-thriller with super secret government organizations, jihads, Machiavellian businessmen,
well executed violence, plausible science and zombies! It was extremely gripping and really that's the only
complaint I had. There were very few pauses in the action where I could set the book down and get some sleep.
I started The Dragon Factory shortly thereafter. After about a third of the way into the book, I realized
something was wrong, but I couldn't quite put my finger on it. It wasn't until I was at the end, skimming my way
through the climax because I didn't really care but wanted to find out how they tied it up that I figured it
out. It started out with the plot feeling slightly contrived to ensure that all factions had the most
amount of contact without actually being aware of what was going on. Next there was the increased scientific
exposition. In the first book, there was just enough to make the premise plausible but they didn't try tp
explain it in any detail so I didn't have to think. In The Dragon Factory everything gets explained
and it's wrong. In some cases it's impossible and in others it's just stupid.
The problem was that Jonathan Maberry jumped genres. Instead of
the very reality based techno thriller of Patient Zero,
he was now writing an over-the-top James Bondesque comic book story complete with super-powered henchmen clones and
immortal Nazi super villains. It wasn't bad (although it was not nearly as well edited as the first book) but
it broke the genre promise of the first and so I paid closer attention to the science thinking it was well
researched instead of made up. I gave the villains's plottings more attention because I thought they were supposed
to be well thought out and not just a madman's doomsday scheme for the hero to stop. I was disappointed
with the killing of the hero's love seemingly there only to harden his resolve and allow him to finish the
fight. Had I been expecting the comic book story, I wouldn't have been nearly so disappointed.
I probably would have forgiven Maberry too, if it weren't for the slapdash epilogue pasted on the end to wrap
up the loose ends and set up the next book. Look at it this way... This book deals with world changing
technology. The villains in the piece have not just resurrected extinct species from the passenger pigeon to
the dodo to a Neanderthal but have created new ones including insect dog hybrids. They have transgenic
processes that can make people stronger, faster and smarter. They've discovered immortality. Unlike
the first book, everyone finds out. Things can't go back to the way they were and yet the book implies
they will. That was not the ending I needed to make up for the genre change.
If you go into this expecting what it is, you'll love it. While not as well written as Patient Zero, it's
still fantastic with tight fight scenes and fascinating exploration of the effects of violence
on the human psyche. However, if you are looking for a realistic plot and not a comic book one, you
might want to give this a pass.
John Enzinas reads frequently and passionately. In his spare time he plays with swords. |
|
|
If you find any errors, typos or anything else worth mentioning,
please send it to editor@sfsite.com.
Copyright © 1996-2013 SF Site All Rights Reserved Worldwide