| Soulsaver | ||||||||
| James Stevens-Arce | ||||||||
| Harcourt Books, 360 pages | ||||||||
|
A review by Victoria Strauss
In this polluted, overcrowded, poverty-ridden environment, where the oceans are brown with sewage and
families live 20 to a one-bedroom apartment, there are a lot of suicides, and Juan and Fabiola are kept
very busy. This suits Juan, who's a good Godfearing Christian and really believes in what he's doing. But
his unthinking acceptance of the world he lives in is about to be tested. Fabiola, it turns out, is a
member of the heretical New Christer cult, which has just been outlawed by the Shepherdess, charismatic
leader of the Christian Alliance. When Juan, dutifully, reports Fabiola to the authorities, he's
recruited to spy on the New Christers.
Eager to assist at first, Juan becomes increasingly uncomfortable with the duplicity of his role. Eventually
he's summoned to meet the leaders of the New Christers, the so-called Twin Messiahs; in this powerful
encounter, all his certainties and assumptions are shattered. Torn between his old loyalties and the new
understandings awakening within him, Juan must face a terrible choice: to take on the role of Judas, and
betray the Twin Messiahs to the Christian Alliance, or to accept the Twins' divinity and become a heretic himself.
Stevens-Arce creates a compelling vision of a far-future America in which official Christian platitudes and
the easy faith of the privileged are countered on every side by decay, violence, poverty, and despair. Juan
goes home at night to his luxury Christian dorm, where he can read a passage or two from The Newer Testament,
plunk down six dollars for a tub of O Little Town of Bethlehem Giant Kernel Popcorn, and watch
Hallelujah Wrestling on TV, where biblically-named wrestlers symbolically re-enact the victory of
Good over Evil. Meanwhile, in the vast, teeming, garbage-heaped slums and housing projects, people are
starving to death; for them, religion is very cold comfort. Juan, a classic unreliable narrator, sees all
of this and none of it; Stevens-Arce is extremely skillful in the way he enables the reader to perceive,
through Juan's devout Christian eyes, the real horror of the world around him.
Stevens-Arce doesn't spend much time on the underpinnings of his setting -- the mechanics of such a vast
political/social transformation, for instance, or the whys and hows of Christian Alliance doctrine, which
sometimes seems Catholic, with its priests and confessionals, and sometimes Protestant charismatic, with its
televangelists and faith healings. This is OK: Soulsaver isn't social commentary, like Margaret
Atwood's The Handmaid's Tale (to which it's been widely -- and in my opinion misleadingly -- compared),
but satire, and as such less dependent upon the literal realities of world building than upon the figurative power
of ideas, and the sharpness with which they skew/reflect a particular reality. And Stevens-Arce's ideas do this
very well indeed, provoking thought not only about the hypocrisy of present-day Christian fundamentalism, but
the historical hypocrisy of the Christian Church as a whole, where concern for the welfare of a soul hasn't
always implied concern for the welfare of the human being to whom the soul belongs.
Soulsaver -- which is written in a lean, punchy style, and moves with jump-cut swiftness from one
scene to the next -- undergoes a major shift in tone toward the end. The satire dims, and the story becomes
a supernatural extravaganza, complete with miracles, resurrections, and an appearance by the Adversary
himself. To my mind, this doesn't entirely work: the political machinations thus exposed are a bit too
predictable, the reversals of fortune a bit too pat, the sudden conversions a bit too easy, and the
Shepherdess's guilt-ridden confession just plain hokey. But this oddly ineffective finish doesn't diminish
the powerful satirical charge of the book's first two-thirds, making Soulsaver a rewarding reading
experience even for those who, like me, might have wished for a more ironic ending.
Victoria Strauss is a novelist, and a lifelong reader of fantasy and science fiction. Her most recent fantasy novel The Garden of the Stone is currently available from HarperCollins EOS. For details, visit her website. |
|||||||
|
|
If you find any errors, typos or anything else worth mentioning,
please send it to editor@sfsite.com.
Copyright © 1996-2013 SF Site All Rights Reserved Worldwide