| Knife of Dreams | ||||||||
| Robert Jordan | ||||||||
| Tor, 784 pages | ||||||||
|
A review by William Thompson
Thus the pace has significantly picked up, and while this may have come at the cost of some resolutions that seem a bit
abbreviated, especially considering the length of buildup, this can perhaps be forgiven by the author's return to a more
active plot progression, more directly seeming to serve his central story. And with sharper focus, the devil no longer
is in the details: while Jordan has not abandoned his love of describing characters and locales, here for the most part
they enrich and contribute to his world creation and storytelling, which have always been the author's greatest
strengths. Reading Knife of Dreams reacquaints one with why they became involved in the series in the first place, as
well as why it has continued to captivate a large audience, retaining loyalty despite voiced dissatisfaction in the
recent stalled progress of the series. Though one begins to suspect intentional padding of the last several
installments, at his best, which this book represents, there is no better bard of high fantasy than Robert Jordan.
Granted, the usual juvenile role-playing now expected of Jordan continues, testing the credulity of a more adult
audience. Recalling some of the Hollywood gender stereotypes of the 30s and 40s, we have plenty of
braid-tugging, sniffing, foot-stamping and hands-on-hips from the part of the tale's heroines; Elayne blaming Rand
for the unpleasant aspects of her pregnancy; and a lot of looks that could kill. Aes Sedai are spanked for
misbehavior. Meanwhile the males of this saga remain utterly baffled by their feminine counterparts, resigned to
a philosophy of can't live with 'em, can't live without 'em. This kind of clichéd battle between the sexes, long
ago overdone in film by the likes of Flynn and Gable, is certain to put off more mature or sophisticated readers,
especially as Jordan obviously delights in revisiting it. Yet high fantasy has always indulged romance in one
form or another, and the continued popularity of romantic fiction and these types of worn-out archetypes may
suggest that Jordan has tapped into role models that retain relevance for a significant portion of his readers,
or that the series has always been aimed at a young-adult audience. It could also be argued, I suppose, that
progress has been made over Tolkien in providing strong, equal roles, however stereotyped or anachronistic. But
this series is unlikely to find adherents among the readers of more serious or literary-minded fantasy.
Nevertheless, even they, if they are fair, must recognize that at his best Jordan is a masterful storyteller, and
that the world he has created, while initially borrowing from Tolkien, has since grown into its own, with an
underlying mythos equaling Middle Earth. Tolkien has had many imitators, but only one true inheritor, and within
this context, it is hard to imagine anyone surpassing Jordan's creation in future. It possesses its flaws, and
there is much to criticize in the glacial pace of the series' last few books. But now that it appears the author
is back on track, and focused on taking the story to its conclusion, one can once again recommend this series,
without too many reservations, and highly to its intended audience.
In addition to the SF Site, William Thompson's reviews have appeared in Interzone, Revolution Science Fiction and Locus Online. He also has worked as a freelance editor for PS Publishing, editing The Healthy Dead and Grandma Matchie, by Steven Erikson, and Night of Knives, by Cameron Esslemont. He lives in Mesilla, New Mexico. |
|||||||
|
|
If you find any errors, typos or anything else worth mentioning,
please send it to editor@sfsite.com.
Copyright © 1996-2013 SF Site All Rights Reserved Worldwide