| Conflicts | ||||||||
| edited by Ian Whates | ||||||||
| NewCon Press, 296 pages | ||||||||
|
A review by Rich Horton
Well, military SF is a pretty standard subgenre: not necessarily a good thing, but its
very standardness implies it's quite a broad subject that has interested a lot of writers
for a long time, and one that continues to have resonance for writers and readers. This
book -- as usual for Whates' anthologies -- includes a pretty good quantity of less familiar
names (particularly to American readers -- all the contributors, as far as I know, are
from the UK) -- and as such we might hope for some surprises. So all in all I expected a lot from the book
-- and perhaps those expectations contribute to a certain disappointment.
Some of this disappointment is simply a matter of taste, no doubt.
For example, Andy Remic's "Psi.copath," set on a planet ravaged by left over war machines, seems intended to
be funny, and for the right reader it might be, but it fell quite flat for this reader.
Differently, I looked forward very much to Chris Beckett's contribution -- he's written some outstanding
stories in recent years -- but his "Our Land", though well-written, seemed too stridently a
by-the-numbers recasting of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict as one between Celts reclaiming Britain
and more-or-less contemporary
English people. And more of the disappointment is just disappointment with decent but not exciting
work -- most of the writers here do solid work, but rarely was I thrilled.
My favorite stories include Gareth L. Powell's "Fallout," in which a woman sort of chaperones a boy band
as they visit a disaster site -- the difference is that the disaster was radiation from a crashed alien
ship -- which of course implies certain possibilities when the boys go exploring. Also, Eric
Brown's "Dissimulation Procedure," one of a generally enjoyable recent series about a starship
captain and his crew. This one is a sort of origin story: the captain, Ed, and his engineer,
Karrie, are looking for a pilot. And one Ella Rodriguez, a beautiful but strange young woman with
a history, comes across them -- and she's a pilot. Of course, she's something else, as well, which
wasn't a surprise to me (as I had seen a couple other stories in this series), but I'll leave
the secret for the reader. At any rate, it's enjoyable if rather slight old-fashioned SF. Finally,
Una McCormick's "War Without End" looks at the losing general of a long concluded war returning
to the planet upon which he failed to stop a revolution. He's a villain to the inhabitants, of
course, and he has his own issues to work through. There's not much new here -- and one could
argue that the story didn't need to be SF, even -- but I found it fairly absorbing.
As I have said, the rest of the book is generally decent work, but never quite
brilliant. Conflicts won't stand as one of the best anthologies of 2010, but it does
offer fair value, all told.
Rich Horton is an eclectic reader in and out of the SF and fantasy genres. He's been reading SF since before the Golden Age (that is, since before he was 13). Born in Naperville, IL, he lives and works (as a Software Engineer for the proverbial Major Aerospace Company) in St. Louis area and is a regular contributor to Tangent. Stop by his website at http://www.sff.net/people/richard.horton. |
|||||||
|
|
If you find any errors, typos or anything else worth mentioning,
please send it to editor@sfsite.com.
Copyright © 1996-2013 SF Site All Rights Reserved Worldwide