Reviews Logo
SearchHomeContents PageSite Map
Tooner's Reviews
Creator and designer of FOLKLORE, Tooner has been into Science Fiction and Fantasy novels for over 15 years. Enjoys Fantasy primarily over Science Fiction, and plans to write an epic of his own.

  • Favorite Authors: David Eddings, Raymond E. Feist, Robert Jordan
  • Favorite book of all time: "Belgarath the Sorcerer", David Eddings
  • The book that started it all: "Ogre Ogre", Piers Anthony
Tooner's Reviews
Piers Anthony, Featured Author
Piers Anthony, "Battle Circle"
Piers Anthony, "Cluster"
Piers Anthony, "Dead Morn" (with Roberto Fuentes)
Piers Anthony, "Mute"
Piers Anthony, "On a Pale Horse"
Terry Brooks, Featured Series
David (and Leigh) Eddings, Featured Series
David (and Leigh) Eddings, "Belgarath the Sorcerer"
Raymond E. Feist, "The King's Buccaneer"
Raymond E. Feist, "Rise of a Merchant Prince"
Alan Dean Foster, "A Call to Arms"
Roberto Fuentes, "Dead Morn" (with Piers Anthony)
Robert A. Heinlein, "Stranger in a Strange Land"
Robert Jordan, "A Crown of Swords"
Stephen King, "The Eyes of the Dragon"
Patrick O'Leary, "Door Number Three"

David's Reviews
"I love good movies. I love good science fiction and fantasy films. I've been watching since I was nine. I have a small library of about 125 books, predominantly mythology, religion and fantasy."

  • Favorite Director: David Lynch
  • Favorite Film(s): (Sci Fi) Blade Runner, (Fantasy) Excalibur
  • Film that started it all: Gamera vs. Baragon
David's Reviews
Dune

TJ's Reviews
Co-designer of FOLKLORE, TJ has been an avid Science Fiction and Fantasy Fan for over 23 years. His personal library contains more than 500 titles. He has no preference of one genre over the other.

  • Favorite Authors: Robert A. Heinlein, Alan Dean Foster, David Drake
  • Favorite book of all time: "The Door into Summer", Robert A. Heinlein
  • The book that started it all: "Starship Troopers", Robert A Heinlein
TJ's Favourites
Poul Anderson, "The Broken Sword"
Robert Asprin, "Phule's Company"
Terry Brooks, "Magic Kingdom for Sale-SOLD!"
Chris Bunch, Featured Series (with Alan Cole)
Robert R. Chase, "The Game of Fox and Lion"
Alan Cole, Featured Series (with Chris Bunch)
Robert Cornett, "The Aldebaran Campaign" (with Kevin Randle)
Stephen R. Donaldson, "Lord Foul's Bane"
David Drake, "The General" (with S. M. Stirling)
David Drake, "Hammer's Slammers"
Mick Farren, "Necrom"
Mick Farren, Featured Author
Alan Dean Foster, "Cyber Way"
Robert A. Frezza, "A Small Colonial War"
W. Michael Gear, "Requiem for the Conqueror"
David Gerrold, "The Voyage of the Star Wolf"
Robert A. Heinlein, "The Number of the Beast"
Robert A. Heinlein, "Starship Troopers"
Frank Herbert, "Dune"
Leo A. Frankowski, Featured Author
Anne McCaffrey, "Dragonflight"
Anne McCaffrey, Featured Series
Andre Norton, "Star Guard"
Frederik Pohl, "Narabedla LTD."
Jerry Pournelle, "The Mercenary"
Kevin Randle, "The Aldebaran Campaign" (with Robert Cornett)
John Steakley, "Armor"
Allen Steele, "Labyrinth of Night"
S. M. Stirling, "The General" (with David Drake)
Harry Turtledove, "Worldwar: In the Balance"
Sydney J. Van Scyoc, "Sunwaifs"
Timothy Zahn, "Cobra (Cobras Two)"


"The Belgariad and Malloreon Series" David (and Leigh) Eddings, Del Rey  
[IMG: 5 Worlds Rating]    Review by Tooner, ©1997

"The Belgariad Series"
  • "Pawn of Prophecy", 1982
  • "Queen of Sorcery", 1982
  • "Magician's Gambit", 1983
  • "Castle of Wizardry", 1984
  • "Enchanter's Endgame", 1984

"The Malloreon Series"
  • "Guardians of the West", 1987
  • "King of the Murgos", 1988
  • "Demon Lord of Karanda", 1988
  • "The Sorceress of Darshiva", 1989
  • "The Seeress of Kell", 1991

"Belgarath the Sorcerer", 1995

"Polgara the Sorceress", 1997
"The Elenium"

  • "The Diamond Throne", 1989 - Del Rey
  • "The Ruby Knight", 1990 - Del Rey
  • "The Sapphire Rose", 1991 - Del Rey

"The Tamuli"

  • "Domes of Fire", 1992 - Del Rey
  • "The Shining Ones", 1993 - Del Rey
  • "The Hidden City", 1994 - Del Rey

"High Hunt", 1973 - Putnam

"The Losers", 1992 - Fawcett Columbine/Del Rey

 

While the Belgariad and the Malloreon are two separate series, they are written as one contagious saga, and I could not separate them. The two individual books flash back to a time prior to the start of the Belgariad, using the same story and characters. Basically, just consider the whole set a series broken up into easy to handle portions.

While I hate to repeat the dreaded cliche "You can't judge a book by its cover", it is true in this case. Before I ever picked up "Pawn of Prophecy", the entire series was recommended to me by several people. Each time, I would look at the horrible art on the cover and read the poor teaser on the back and put it right back down again. Finally, I bought the first book and took a chance, and I am glad I did.

This is, by far, the best Fantasy series I have ever read. I have never, before or since, found characters with as much depth and believable human emotion. Every nuance and character flaw, every major scenario and minor situation, full with real life and color.

Simply put, this is a series you pick up and don't put down until every book is completed. I spent several hours one evening searching every bookstore in town trying to find the "King of the Murgos". so I could continue where the last book left off. The two months between when I completed the final book in the Malloreon series and the release of "Belgarath the Sorcerer" were grueling. I couldn't pick up another book, as if it would have tainted my enjoyment of the new story.

I missed interacting with the characters when I finished the last book and I am still anxiously awaiting the release of "Polgara the Sorceress". This series is a true MUST HAVE for all Fantasy fans.

Simply the best character writer I have ever read. I was reluctant to read his work at first, despite the numerous recommendations from friends. Once I picked up "Pawn of the Prophecy", I didn't stop till I had read all of the "Belgariad", "Malloreon", "Elenium" and "Tamuli" series. When I finished reading "Belgarath the Sorcerer", I actually went into "Eddings withdrawal". I couldn't pick up another author for several weeks and kept having "Garion flashbacks". :)

Seriously, Eddings creates complete characters, real and enjoyable, that any reader can relate with. I was also very impressed when reading the "Elenium"and "Tamuli" series, that they where not rehashed versions of the "Belgariad" and "Malloreon", but serious stories full of new complex characters and plots.

Recently, David Eddings gave credit to his wife, Leigh Eddings, for assisting him with all of his previous works. This team has put together an unbelievable collection of top notch novels, and I look forward to reading anything they produce in the future.



"Belgarath the Sorcerer", David and Leigh Eddings, ©1995  
[IMG: 5 Worlds Rating]    Review by Tooner, ©1997

 
[IMG: Book Cover] A Del Ray® Book, Published by Ballantine Books, July 1996 - Gatefold Map (Cover art) by Larry Schwinger, ©1995
For fans of the Belgariad and Malloreon series, this book is a definite must have. As the two series came to a close, there were a lot of unanswered questions since the plot started prior to the actual start of the series. "Belgarath The Sorcerer"focuses on a main character from the two series, and shows how he came to fill the role he now plays, as well as where the story begins. The story adds depth to the original situations from the earlier series, making you want to reread them again, but the novel is so well written it stands by itself and would be an enjoyable read alone.

As usual, the characters created by Eddings are rich and full of life. When I finished this book, and the two series, I actually missed reading about the characters. I am patiently awaiting the next in this follow up series, "Polgara The Sorceress".


"The Landover Series", Terry Brooks, Del Rey Science Fiction  
[IMG: 1 World Rating]    Review by Tooner, ©1997

  • "Magic Kingdom For Sale, Sold", April 1986 - Del Rey
  • "The Black Unicorn", October 1987 - Del Rey
  • "Wizard at Large", August 1989 - Del Rey
  • "Witch's Brew", April 1995 - Del Rey
  • "Tangle Box", April 1995 - Del Rey
The best story lines I have ever read... for Saturday morning cartoons. I don't remember what evil spirits possessed me to read the first Landover book "Magic Kingdom for Sale-SOLD!". It was the same cliche Fantasy novel with a twist... the writing was immature too. After that, I forced myself to read the second and third books (I must have been into mental masturbation at the time). They had to get better, right? Wrong. They were worse than the first. Luckily, Brooks took a break on the series and I got out of my slump and returned to reading adult novels. I have never been able to bring myself to pick up the two new editions in the series.

There are thousands of Fantasy novels out there that use the same basic plot with little nuances. Brook's novels try to do that and fail. The writing is poor, suitable for 12 year old girls who still believe in pink dragons, and that's if you remove the cheesy and blatant sexual innuendos. The characters are transparent, the backdrops are cartoonish and the conflicts are flimsy. The super persona that possesses the main character and saves the day is down right pathetic.

I have been told that Brook's Shannara series is excellent, but after the Landover series, I can't find the strength to read it.


SearchContents PageSite MapContact UsCopyright

If you find any errors, typos or other stuff worth mentioning, please send it to editor@sfsite.com.
Copyright © 1996, 1997, 1998 SF Site All Rights Reserved Worldwide