| | | |
|
|
| 4 | Terri Windling | Summation 1990: Fantasy |
| 4 | Ellen Datlow | Summation 1990: Horror |
| 4 | Edward Bryant | Horror and Fantasy in the Media: 1990 |
| 4 | James Frenkel | Obituaries: 1990 |
| 4 | Charles de Lint | Freewheeling |
| 4 | Nina Kiriki Hoffman | Coming Home |
| 4 | George Szanto | The Sweeper |
| 4 | Joyce Carol Oates | Ladies and Gentlemen |
| 4 | Nancy A. Collins | Freaktent |
| 4 | John Crowley | Missolonghi 1824 |
| 4 | Thomas Ligotti | The Last Feast of Harlequin |
| 4 | David Memmott | Sounding the Praises of Shadow to the Merchants of Light |
| 4 | Kristine Kathryn Rusch | Harvest |
| 4 | Susan Cooper | Fantasy in the Real World |
| 4 | Dyan Sheldon | The Dream |
| 4 | John Brunner | Moths |
| 4 | Susan Prospere | Frozen Charlottes |
| 4 | Rachel Simon | Little Nightmares, Little Dreams |
| 4 | John Morressy | Timekeeper |
| 4 | Ellen Kushner | Sonata: For Two Friends in Different Times of the Same Trouble |
| 4 | Stuart Dybek | Death of a Right Fielder |
| 4 | David J. Schow | Not from Around Here |
| 4 | Karen Joy Fowler | Lieserl |
| 4 | Sharon M. Hall | The Last Game |
| 4 | Susan Palwick | Offerings |
| 4 | Vern Rutsala | The Muses of Rooms |
| 4 | Nina Kiriki Hoffman | A Touch of the Old Lilith |
| 4 | David B. Silva | The Calling |
| 4 | Haruki Murakami; trans. by Alfred Birnbaum | TV People |
| 4 | Steve Rasnic Tem | In the Trees |
| 4 | Garry Kilworth | Truman Capote's Trilby: The Facts |
| 4 | Ian R. MacLeod | Green |
| 4 | Garry Kilworth | Dark Hills, Hollow Clocks |
| 4 | Jonathan Carroll | The Panic Hand |
| 4 | Michael Blumlein | Bestseller |
| 4 | Delia Sherman | Nanny Peters and the Feathery Bride |
| 4 | Jack Womack | Out of Sight, Out of Mind |
| 4 | Éilis Ní Dhuibhne | Midwife to the Fairies |
| 4 | Joe R. Lansdale | The Phone Woman |
| 4 | T. E. D. Klein | Ladder |
| 4 | Steven Millhauser | Alice, Falling |
| 4 | Angela Carter | Ashputtle: or, The Mother's Ghost |
| 4 | Adrian Cole | Face to Face |
| 4 | Karel Capek | The Dog's Tale |
| 4 | Elizabeth Massie | Stephen |
| 4 | Peter Straub | A Short Guide to the City |
| 4 | R. A. Lafferty | The Story of Little Briar-Rose, A Scholarly Study |
| 4 | K. W. Jeter | The First Time |
| 4 | Ian Frazier | Coyote vs. Acme |
| 4 | Richard Christian Matheson | Arousal |
| 4 | Gwen Strauss | The Waiting Wolf |
| 4 | Gwen Strauss | The Beast |
| 4 | Isabel Allende; trans. by Margaret Sayers Peden | Two Words |
| 4 | Lucius Shepard & Robert Frazier | The All-Consuming |
| 4 | Jonathan Carroll | The Sadness of Detail |
| 4 | Michael Bishop | Snapshots from the Butterfly Plague |
| 4 | | Honorable Mentions: 1990 |
|
|
| 5 | Terri Windling | Summation 1991: Fantasy |
| 5 | Ellen Datlow | Summation 1991: Horror |
| 5 | Edward Bryant | Horror and Fantasy in the Media: 1991 |
| 5 | James Frenkel | Obituaries: 1991 |
| 5 | David Morrell | The Beautiful Uncut Hair of Graves |
| 5 | Nancy Springer | In Carnation |
| 5 | Fred Chappell | The Somewhere Doors |
| 5 | R. H. W. Dillard | Poe at the End |
| 5 | Kathe Koja | Angels in Love |
| 5 | Midori Snyder | Vivian |
| 5 | K. W. Jeter | True Love |
| 5 | A. R. Morlan | The Second Most Beautiful Woman in the World |
| 5 | Ellen Kushner | The Swordsman Whose Name Was Not Death |
| 5 | Robert Holdstock & Garry Kilworth | The Ragthorn |
| 5 | Patrick McGrath | The Smell |
| 5 | Steve Rasnic & Melanie Tem | The Tenth Scholar |
| 5 | Jessica Amanda Salmonson | Fisher Death |
| 5 | Jessica Amanda Salmonson | Walk in Sable |
| 5 | Norman Partridge | The Cut Man |
| 5 | Karl Edward Wagner | The Kind Men Like |
| 5 | Terry Bisson | The Coon Suit |
| 5 | Alison Fell | Queen Christina and the Windsurfer |
| 5 | S. P. Somtow | Chui Chai |
| 5 | Jane Yolen | Mama Gone |
| 5 | Pat Murphy | Peter |
| 5 | Charles de Lint | Our Lady of the Harbour |
| 5 | Stephen Gallagher | The Visitors' Book |
| 5 | Steve Rasnic Tem | At the End of the Day |
| 5 | Nina Katerli; trans. by Bernard Meares | The Monster |
| 5 | Lisa Mason | Hummers |
| 5 | James Powell | Santa's Way |
| 5 | Dennis Etchison | Call Home |
| 5 | Grant Morrison | The Braille Encyclopaedia |
| 5 | Rosario Ferr‚ | The Poisoned Story |
| 5 | Janice Galloway | Blood |
| 5 | Nancy Willard | Dogstar Man |
| 5 | Joanne Greenberg | Persistence of Memory |
| 5 | Adam Gopnik | You'll Never Eat Lunch on This Continent Again |
| 5 | Thomas Ligotti | The Glamour |
| 5 | Kara Dalkey | The Peony Lantern |
| 5 | Nancy Springer | To Be a Hero |
| 5 | Ramsey Campbell | The Same in Any Language |
| 5 | Kathe Koja | Teratisms |
| 5 | Kobo Abe | The Life of a Poet |
| 5 | Gloria Ericson | The Witch of Wilton Falls |
| 5 | Pat Cadigan | Home by the Sea |
| 5 | Nancy Willard | Pish, Posh, Said Hieronymous Bosch |
| 5 | Poppy Z. Brite | The Ash of Memory, the Dust of Desire |
| 5 | S. P. Somtow | The Pavilion of Frozen Women |
| 5 | Carol Emshwiller | Moon Songs |
| 5 | Ian Frazier | The Afternoon of June 8, 1991 |
| 5 | C. J. Cherryh | Gwydion and the Dragon |
| 5 | Jane Yolen | A Story Must Be Held |
| 5 | Pierrette Fleutiaux | The Ogre's Wife |
| 5 | | Honorable Mentions: 1991 |
|
|
| 6 | Terri Windling | Summation 1992: Fantasy |
| 6 | Ellen Datlow | Summation 1992: Horror |
| 6 | Edward Bryant | Horror and Fantasy in the Media: 1992 |
| 6 | James Frenkel | Obituaries: 1992 |
| 6 | Emma Bull | Silver or Gold |
| 6 | Jack Cady | Tinker |
| 6 | Craig Curtis | Queequeg |
| 6 | M. John Harrison | Anima |
| 6 | Steve Rasnic Tem | Skin |
| 6 | Reginald McKnight | The Homunculus: A Novel in One Chapter |
| 6 | Cristina Peri Rossi; trans. by Mary Jane Tracy | The Annunciation |
| 6 | Charles de Lint | The Bone Woman |
| 6 | A. S. Byatt | The Story of the Eldest Princess |
| 6 | Poppy Z. Brite | Calcutta, Lord of Nerves |
| 6 | Jessica Amanda Salmonson | In the Looking Glass, Life Is Death |
| 6 | Scott Bradfield | The Parakeet and the Cat |
| 6 | Nicholas Royle | Glory |
| 6 | Neil Gaiman | Murder Mysteries |
| 6 | Steve Rasnic Tem | Hungry |
| 6 | M. R. Scofidio | Playing With |
| 6 | Edward Bryant | Human Remains |
| 6 | Robert Silverberg | It Comes and Goes |
| 6 | Grozdana Olujic; trans. by Jascha Kessler | The Bewitched Burr |
| 6 | Charlotte Watson Sherman | Swimming Lesson |
| 6 | Garry Kilworth | Memories of the Flying Ball Bike Shop |
| 6 | Diane de Avalle-Arce | Bats |
| 6 | Nancy Farmer | Origami Mountain |
| 6 | James Powell | Ruby Laughter, Tears of Pearl |
| 6 | Judith Tarr | I Sing of a Maiden |
| 6 | Cliff Burns | Also Starring |
| 6 | Christopher Fowler | On Edge |
| 6 | Joyce Carol Oates | Martyrdom |
| 6 | Haruki Murakami; trans. by Jay Rubin | The Second Bakery Attack |
| 6 | Lucius Shepard | A Little Night Music |
| 6 | Jo Shapcott | Tom and Jerry visit England |
| 6 | Stephen Gallagher | The Sluice |
| 6 | Brian W. Aldiss | Ratbird |
| 6 | Gene Wolfe | The Sailor Who Sailed After the Sun |
| 6 | Rick Bowes | On Death and the Deuce |
| 6 | Harlan Ellison | The Man Who Rowed Christopher Columbus Ashore |
| 6 | Joe Haldeman | Graves |
| 6 | Ed Gorman | The Ugly File |
| 6 | Midori Snyder | Elfhouses |
| 6 | Sue Ellen Sloca | Candles on the Pond |
| 6 | Grania Davis | Tree of Life, Book of Death |
| 6 | D. R. McBride | Puja |
| 6 | Clive Barker | Hermione and the Moon |
| 6 | Graham Masterton | Absence of Beast |
| 6 | Steve Rasnic Tem | Rat Catcher |
| 6 | Jane Yolen | Will |
| 6 | Jane Yolen | The Question of the Grail |
| 6 | John Brunner | In the Season of the Dressing of the Wells |
| 6 | Sara Gallardo; trans. by Elizabeth Rhodes | The Blue Stone Emperor's Thirty-Three Wives |
| 6 | Angela Carter | Alice in Prague, or The Curious Room |
| 6 | Lisa Tuttle | Replacements |
| 6 | Peter Straub | The Ghost Village |
| 6 | | Honorable Mentions: 1992 |