A Case Of Conscience | |||||
James Blish | |||||
Victor Gollancz, 192 pages | |||||
A review by Martin Lewis
This brings up a serious flaw in the novel: the depiction of Agronski and Carver. Carver is portrayed as stupid, xenophobic and
venal to a degree that undermines the credibility of his selection, and his plan for Lithia is simply laughable. Agronski on the
other hand has no characterization at all; he is simply a blank slate. This means a lot of the tension generated in the build- up to the discussion is dissipated. However Ruiz-Sanchez, a priest as well as a biologist, has
an even more radical conclusion: that Lithia should be placed in
permanent quarantine because it is a creation of the devil. In doing so he has committed heresy since this belief, Manichaeanism,
is against Catholic dogma.
As an atheist interpreting an agnostic's depiction of Catholic theology several decades after the fact, I don't find this entirely
persuasive but this does not really matter. James Blish notes in his foreword that it was his intention to write "about a man, not
a body of doctrine." He largely succeeds in this; his portrayal of the deeply conflicted Father Ruiz-Sanchez is the core of this section.
It is Blish's writing that is the real joy here; compared to that of a fellow Futurian like Isaac Asimov, his writing is a
revelation. His depiction of Ruiz-Sanchez and the Lithian society would not look out of place published today, in
stark contrast to most 50s SF.
The second half of the novel is set on Earth and charts the development of a Lithian specimen from embryo
to TV star. This Lithian, Egtverchi, is a catalyst for social change that touches the lives of all the original contact team.
Again Blish's writing is ahead of the field but this time only as far as the 70s. His depiction of Earth is reminiscent
of that of John Brunner's Stand On Zanzibar and Thomas Disch's 334, though without
the stylistic experimentation of the New Wave writers.
The satiric tone of the second half is in marked contrast to that of the first and this is not necessarily for the best. Likewise
the relegation of Ruiz-Sanchez from centre stage to the role of supporting player. This dissonance is also present in a superfluous
scientific appendix that detracts jarringly from the ending.
The ending itself, however, is well-written and thoughtful, and provides a final solution to the problem of Lithia and Egtverchi.
Blish is certainly a historically important author and should be read for that reason alone. However, you can't help thinking that
if the novel had been written as a whole, the results would have been more satisfying. Nevertheless A Case Of Conscience has aged well
and, for all its flaws, holds its own with any SF published in the last 50 years.
Martin Lewis lives in South London; he is originally from Bradford, UK. He writes book reviews for The Telegraph And Argus. |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
If you find any errors, typos or anything else worth mentioning,
please send it to editor@sfsite.com.
Copyright © 1996-2014 SF Site All Rights Reserved Worldwide