Visionary in Residence | ||||||||
Bruce Sterling | ||||||||
Thunder's Mouth Press, 320 pages | ||||||||
|
A review by Paul Kincaid
The point in this collection about which the book turns (almost literally so, since it has been placed in the middle pages),
is not even the sole work of the author, it is a collaboration with Paul Di Filippo. "The Scab's Progress" is the longest
work, its title suggesting a kinship with Hogarth's "The Rake's Progress," and it is as episodic as the original, but where
Hogarth's social satire progressed through a series of logical and inevitable consequences, each successive incident
in "The Scab's Progress" is neither the logical nor the inevitable consequence of its predecessor. The "scab"
of the title is a bio-hacker, but the information contained in gene types is of a very different character to the information
that is the common currency of cyberpunk, and the authors don't seem to have any awareness of this disjunction (the fact
that they conclude their tale with a glossary, even one full of in-jokes, further suggests an uncertainty about the coherence
of their world). And where the Rake was set on an inevitable downward course, the Scab somehow achieves a happy ending that
makes no sense whatever after the sequence of daft disasters that precede it. "The Scab's Progress" is a rollicking tale full
of nifty ideas and some neat set-pieces, but as you read through it you are struck with the realisation that none of this holds together.
The characteristic of "The Scab's Progress" that is replicated across this collection is the fact that it is full of ideas but
doesn't actually have much in the way of story to hold those ideas together and make them work. There are, for instance, three
of those irritating bugbears of modern SF by big-name authors: the very short story written for Nature. It takes a special
talent to write 800 words that work as a cohesive and effective story, and most of the contributions to Nature that I have seen
do not display that talent. Sterling is no exception; what we get instead is three sketches that might become stories if they
were subjected to more development. If all you want is the idea, baldly expressed (and SF is the literature of ideas, surely)
then these are fine; if you demand anything more of your fiction, you might as well skip these pages.
This sense of laying out ideas but not worrying too much about the mechanics of story is common in longer pieces here also. "Luciferase"
gives human speech patterns (and supposedly comic names like "Vinnie") to a firefly and its predator, but other than that
simply presents their life cycle from a different, more knowing, perspective. "The Growthing" is set in the computer-designed
"architecture" of Greg Lynn, "the modern master of... 'blobitecture'", but an inconsequential story does nothing remotely
interesting with the setting. The other collaboration in this collection, "Junk DNA," written with Rudy Rucker, is another story
in which biological ideas are appropriated to cyberpunk tropes, with a satire on contemporary business thrown into the mix,
and it really doesn't mix. What starts out promisingly -- a hapless bunch of people out of their depth in the business world
attempt to market a new toy constructed from junk DNA -- becomes increasingly silly. The escalation of the pace from stately
to tearaway in the last few pages suggests that the authors themselves had no clear idea where they were going with this idea.
Which is not to say that Visionary in Residence is a collection of complete duds; there
are stories which promise more, and one or two which come
close to delivering. "The Denial" is a ghost story with a neat twist, even if it is telegraphed halfway
through. "User-Centric" starts out wonderfully as an exchange of emails between design geeks imagining the end user for
their latest creation, but then just over halfway through crashes to Earth when the whole focus of the story
shifts. "In Paradise" is a superb satire in which an American and his Iranian lover evade high-tech surveillance by simply
walking away, their escape aided when immigration officials bus them across the Mexican border as unwanted aliens; unfortunately
the satire seems to be the part of the story that interests Sterling least. The best piece gathered here is what Sterling
terms his "mainstream" story, "Code," about a programmer who woos a receptionist by using books on how to win your man
as the programme for how to conduct a romance. It is sly, witty, inventive, which is what makes it stand out from the
stories that surround it.
Paul Kincaid is the administrator of the Arthur C. Clarke Award and reviews for most of the critical journals in science fiction, as well as contributing to numerous reference books. |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
If you find any errors, typos or anything else worth mentioning,
please send it to editor@sfsite.com.
Copyright © 1996-2014 SF Site All Rights Reserved Worldwide