Slippage: Previously Uncollected, Precariously Poised Stories | |||||||||||||
Harlan Ellison | |||||||||||||
Mariner Books, 352 pages | |||||||||||||
|
A review by Thomas Myer
There are no surprises in this, Ellison's latest collection of stories.
This is good news and bad news. I'll give you the good news first.
The good news is that the stories are Grade-A premium quality, that
they are filled with words both unusual and delightful, and
that these words are arranged in pleasing sentences. Furthermore, just
about all these sentences form aesthetic paragraphs.
The bad news is, Ellison is starting to plagiarize himself.
These stories mark no departure for Ellison, who, granted, must be on to
something, otherwise he wouldn't be winning all those stinkin' awards.
However, his characters, whether telepath, loan shark, soldier, time traveler,
or intergalactic being, are all the same fella: a short loudmouth with a Yiddish
disposition.
Don't get me wrong. I've enjoyed Ellison's work for many,
many years. And I've bought a lot of his books. But Ellison is starting
to sound much like AC/DC: the same riffs, the same beats, over and over
and over and over again.
If you are a fan, then this might disturb you. If you are not, you might
enjoy stories like "Mefisto in Onyx" in which
an African-American telepath is asked by the woman he loves, a white District
Attorney, to waltz into the mind of a mass murderer to determine if the man is
truly innocent, as his lawyers claim. Though the situation is new,
the method, the process, the execution is the same. None of this has changed.
It's like reading "I Have No Mouth and I Must Scream" repeatedly,
without a break.
There's something else that bothered me about this book -- Ellison's
attitude toward young people and Internet users. Keep in mind that
I'm 26 and make a living from computer technology and the Web. Those
facts alone may be enough to dismiss my thoughts as mere bias. But
here goes: in the introduction of Slippage, and in other places as well, Ellison
has gone out of his way to deride young people for lacking aesthetic sensibility,
smarts, cultural atonement, et cetera. It appears that if we don't know
who Ronald Coleman is, then we're somehow illiterate simpletons.
There is, of course, another way of viewing this, and it breaks
my heart to say it: Harlan, baby, you have become irrelevant.
You can't keep up with the world. With all the amazing stuff that happens
every day. Just thinking about Web technology and how it's evolving makes
my head spin; and that only accounts for about 1/900th of what the human
race is doing technologically. Harlan, you don't even own a computer, for
God's sake. Nor do you spend time on the Web, which is pretty funny considering
you've called Web denizens both pinheaded and cowardly. That's sorta equivalent
to the preacher denouncing pornography when he's never even cracked
open a Playboy. Oh, you've said that you're not anti-technology, but saying that
once can't
drown out the other times you've
slammed technophiles.
Ellison has said, in print and on cable, that he's
deathly afraid
that he'll be forgotten as a writer. Well, I see no better way
to slide into the pit of anonymity than to alienate the young and the technologically
hip. We are the future. Ignore us, deride us, forget us, and we'll bury you.
Thomas Myer is a technical writer. He happens to have an amazing collection of enemies. |
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() |
If you find any errors, typos or other stuff worth mentioning,
please send it to editor@sfsite.com.
Copyright © 1996-2014 SF Site All Rights Reserved Worldwide